Well, obviously. However, can you honestly say that The Witcher, an epic 50+ hour RPG, has an inferior storyline to Portal, a sub-three hour puzzler? I liked Portal, sure, but I can't agree that it had the best story of the year.
Does that mean all books with over 300 pages are better than books with less than 300 pages? bah.
They could have stretched Portal to 50+ if they made you do a bunch of crap that didn't matter....now, that being said, I still want to try out Witcher....
I will make Witcher a 2008 GoTY since that is when I will play. Supporter of the Cell Phone Jamming movement.