Carmack on Game Patents

This post from John Carmack (thanks Frans) offers a comment from the id Software technical director on patenting technologies used in video games. The post responds to this Slashdot thread about the legal beagles who have launched The Patent Arcade attempting to encourage more game technology patents (since that would be an opportunity to drink from an untapped revenue stream). Here's Mr. Carmack's take:
I'm proud that there is "a relative dearth of patent applications for the video game industry, especially considering how technology-dependent the video game industry is, and given its size in terms of annual sales."

Before issuing a condemnation, I try hard to think about it from their point of view -- the laws of the land set the rules of the game, and lawyers are deeply confused at why some of us aren't using all the tools that the game gives us.

Patents are usually discussed in the context of someone "stealing" an idea from the long suffering lone inventor that devoted his life to creating this one brilliant idea, blah blah blah.

But in the majority of cases in software, patents effect independent invention. Get a dozen sharp programmers together, give them all a hard problem to work on, and a bunch of them will come up with solutions that would probably be patentable, and be similar enough that the first programmer to file the patent could sue the others for patent infringement.

Why should society reward that? What benefit does it bring? It doesn't help bring more, better, or cheaper products to market. Those all come from competition, not arbitrary monopolies. The programmer that filed the patent didn't work any harder because a patent might be available, solving the problem was his job and he had to do it anyway. Getting a patent is uncorrelated to any positive attributes, and just serves to allow either money or wasted effort to be extorted from generally unsuspecting and innocent people or companies.

Yes, it is a legal tool that may help you against your competitors, but I'll have no part of it. Its basically mugging someone.

I could waste hours going on about this. I really need to just write a position paper some day that I can cut and paste when this topic comes up.
View : : :
4.
 
Blimey
Jun 2, 2005, 11:45
4.
Blimey Jun 2, 2005, 11:45
Jun 2, 2005, 11:45
 
An impressive (and correct, imho) attitude to take there by Mr Carmack.

However, one can't help wondering if he would feel the same if he was back to square one with no money and people ripping his work off left, right and centre...
I'd rather die peacefully in my sleep like my Grandfather,
than screaming in terror like his passengers.- Jim Harkins
http://www.Horrible.Demon.co.uk/
Date
Subject
Author
1.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
2.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
7.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
21.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
14.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
3.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
 4.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
Blimey
5.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
6.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
24.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
27.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
    Re: Blimey
12.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
25.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
26.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
    Re: Blimey
28.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005
     Re: Blimey
32.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005
      Re: Blimey
33.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005
       Re: Blimey
35.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005
        Re: Blimey
11.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
13.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
8.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
9.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
10.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
15.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
23.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
17.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
18.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
19.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
20.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
   Re: SCUM!
22.
Jun 2, 2005Jun 2 2005
29.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005
31.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005
34.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005
30.
Jun 3, 2005Jun 3 2005