Kobalt, who made your definition of MMORPG the official one?
Every single mmorpg on the market, from asheron's call to final fantasy 11
What genre would you call it?
Same one diablo and nwn is I would imagine
Why is every major gaming website (okay, except for IGN) referring to it as a MMORPG?
Mmorpgs is a nich market to say the least(though this is changing), and if you read reviews of mmorpgs usually they hardly know anything about the genre.
So, every gaming site/magazine thinks it's a mmorpg because they don't know much about the genre and anet said it was a mmorpg(anet is running a creative campaign, one sentence say its not a mmorpg so people dont flame them for false advertising, the next they say its a mmorpg with no monthly fee).
while all you have done is explain how it is an unconventional MMORPG
This argument is weak because it can be used anywhere. Im sure there are arguments calling action games with a little rpg element thrown in a "uncoventional" rpg. Still wrong though
All I know is that Arenanet set out to make something different from anything before it, and your argument proves that they have succeeded.
Well if it proved one thing, is that there are alot of retards on these forums