Damn Edit button...
...what truly defines a PC game or a console game?There is no TRUE definition of a console game or a PC game. Most of the times, it's schleps on some forum somewhere that condemn a game to be one or the other. If a game is simple, it automatically must be a "console game", as if that is a derogatory term or something. And also apparently ignoring the fact that there are a LOT of just excellent games coming out on the consoles, as well as the occasional innovative game. (Pikmin, Katahacy Damahoohoowhatever, although you could say that that was really just an evolution of a really old C64 game that did much the same thing. Marble Madness, I think it was called?)
When was the last time we saw something INNOVATIVE on the PC?
I buy more games for my PC than I do for my consoles, but when a great console game comes out, I enjoy it just as much (shit, probably more) as I do my PC games. And I don't have to try to reinstall five different drivers to get the fucking thing to work.
I'm in line for the Xbox360, I'll probably get the PSX3 as well (although I'll wait for some quality games to come out for that one).
I think if PC gamers would get down from their little ivory tower and see the quality of certain console games, this whole debate will just vanish.
Both PCs and consoles have advantages and disadvantages. With the next gen consoles, the difference between the two will dwindle to really just marginal proportions (controller and memory, mostly). There are a ton of shitty games coming out on consoles, but so are there for PCs. When both systems get a quality game, it's a quality game, and when you're playing it, does it really matter whether you're playing it on your 2000 dollar PC, or your 300 dollar Xbox360?
Yes, a FPS works better on a PC. Similarly, a fighting game or a sports game, works better on a console. Why not be glad we have different systems that can embrace the different genres and turn each into better games, rather than playing everything on the same generic platform? I've played fighting games with mouse and keyboard, and it's just not as great as a controller. Similarly, I shiver at the thought of Half Life 2 with a controller, rather than a keyboard or mouse.
If you're firmly in the "Consoles suck" camp, you're missing out on a TON of great games.
Can't wait to get back home to play more Jade Empire
Creston