Graphics wise... eh.... I don't deal well with plastic monsters. And while it has some really nice scripted events that used the graphics, like when ya met the first scientist, overall the graphics were merely ok. What's really funny is how much of the graphics have been chopped up for the Xbox version, including no outside locations as far as i have played through it.
But graphics are nothing if there isn't a complete package. And Doom 3 was far from a complete package.
How are stil scared by monster closets? About the time I hit the Delta Lab I was so bored with the cheap shots it was ridculous. I mean if I want a good scare I'll load up AvP 1 or 2.
I mean what happened to the stuff they had in the tech demo and that they showed in game when Hell was unleashed on Mars? It was turned into pre-rendered movies you might see a little bit of if you aren't trying to watch all the special fx happening behind ya at the begining of the game.