I just played 30 minutes of Doom3 having got home from work (arrived this morning - go Amazon!)... and is it just me, or is it rather, well, flat? I didn't feel drawn in, or really that involved. It just annoyed me by being rather dark, having to flip to the flashlight every other second... I might play for another 30 minutes tomorrow, but right now there's nothing there to make me want to play it any more. As far as I can tell, the aim is to walk between badly-lit rooms and expect something to burst out of a wall, such that you can switch to a weapon, lose sight of it, shoot, miss, switch back to the torch, find it again, and repeat. Just seems a bit empty... in fact, all I want to do now is go play the original. It's more fun, even if it is a whole lot simpler.
Maybe I'm not in the right mood... or perhaps I'm not the intended audience, but I learnt a lot from Doom 1... it's why I do what I do and why I enjoy doing it. Doom 1 was fun. And that's an important word.
If HL2 doesn't deliver, I might kerplode. That's right, 'kerplode'. But HL2 is different. But this is a Doom thread, so I won't mention HL2 anymore. Not once. HL2. Hah.