Ok, give me 5 reasons, other than graphics, that Doom 3 is the best FPS to come out in the last 3-4 years. Why does it deserve a better score (94 than any other FPS during that time?
Now
that's a good question. I've already given up waiting for responses to my vid card question so I may as well watch this debate unfold.
For what it's worth, every message board I've been on features very similar opinions on Doom 3: a majority of "great engine, bad game" and at the same time, a vast minority of "a classic FPS, the best shooter in years."