|
 |
| [Jul 21, 2004, 09:24 am ET] - Share - Viewing Comments |
A Q&A on nine inch nails access
(thanks Not One Of Us) offers Trent Reznor's take on why he did not end up
working on the DOOM 3 soundtrack as planned. Here's the deal on what happened,
and Trent's guess about who ended up doing the theme song: john carmack and i
had established a friendship while working on quake. he came to see up playing
during the last tour and wanted to get my feelings on a remake of doom with a
new advanced engine he was working on. we discussed how cool it would be to
create a place that was immersive to the point it wouldn't need a "soundtrack"
-- the technology was advanced enough to visually and aurally to create a rich
environment you could truly explore and inhabit. we discussed my involvement as
the overall sound producer -- from foley and voice over to ambient world noise.
later, i started work on what would be used at the e3 show 2 years ago. it was
exciting working in a totally new way with new tools. i was working directly in
the game editor and with the programmers refining the sound code and helping the
environment come alive. tried "tuning" various environmental sound sources so
they'd cohesively interact with on another in a "musical" way. the advanced
technology provided enough horsepower to give me a seemingly limitless amount of
freedom. it was a lot of work, a lot of thinking in a different way, and a
lot of fun. i was working with the best guys in the field -- true geniuses.
out idea was to have no music, apart from a main theme i'd write for the intro.
no rock, nothing current sounding, nothing to date the game.
well... eventually time and money and bad management came into play and it
didn't work out. disappointing on a number of levels for me, but that's the way
it went.
I have seen the engine at work and it is great. i'm looking forward to seeing
what they've done with the game.
and i guess tool did the theme song
 |
140. |
Re: No subject |
Jul 21, 2004, 17:56 |
S_DOG34 |
|
Haha space captain. The mental image I get of you furiously pounding on your keyboard to defend your 'honor' is priceless. For as well liked as you are on these forums I bet you are one helluva winner in real life.
Dunder-head.
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
Date |
Subject |
Author |
|
1. |
Jul 21, 09:29 |
Re: No subject |
Overon |
|
2. |
Jul 21, 09:34 |
Re: No subject |
Veinman |
|
3. |
Jul 21, 09:38 |
Re: No subject |
Apathy Curve |
|
4. |
Jul 21, 10:10 |
Re: No subject |
ExcessDan |
|
5. |
Jul 21, 10:14 |
Re: No subject |
nin |
|
11. |
Jul 21, 10:28 |
Re: No subject |
sc4r4b |
|
13. |
Jul 21, 10:33 |
Re: No subject |
sc4r4b |
|
21. |
Jul 21, 10:51 |
Re: oh my |
Fingers M |
|
6. |
Jul 21, 10:14 |
Re: No subject |
Hollow Man |
|
7. |
Jul 21, 10:20 |
Re: No subject |
ExcessDan |
|
77. |
Jul 21, 13:28 |
Re: No subject |
MindTrigger |
|
82. |
Jul 21, 13:46 |
Re: No subject |
heroin |
|
85. |
Jul 21, 13:52 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
8. |
Jul 21, 10:20 |
Doom3 Soundtrack |
jack shiznit |
|
9. |
Jul 21, 10:25 |
Re: Doom3 Soundtrack |
toT |
|
10. |
Jul 21, 10:28 |
Re: Doom3 Soundtrack |
ExcessDan |
|
12. |
Jul 21, 10:30 |
Re: No subject |
space captain |
|
15. |
Jul 21, 10:40 |
Re: No subject |
ExcessDan |
|
14. |
Jul 21, 10:38 |
Bobby |
Rethcir |
|
16. |
Jul 21, 10:44 |
asdf |
a |
|
17. |
Jul 21, 10:46 |
Re: asdf |
ExcessDan |
|
22. |
Jul 21, 10:51 |
Re: asdf |
nin |
|
25. |
Jul 21, 10:57 |
Re: asdf |
Hurcules |
|
18. |
Jul 21, 10:46 |
if the shoe fits |
space captain |
|
19. |
Jul 21, 10:50 |
Re: if the shoe fits |
sinner's saint |
|
20. |
Jul 21, 10:51 |
Re: if the shoe fits |
sinner's saint |
|
23. |
Jul 21, 10:53 |
Re: if the shoe fits |
ExcessDan |
|
24. |
Jul 21, 10:55 |
Re: if the shoe fits |
nin |
|
26. |
Jul 21, 11:00 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
Flood |
|
27. |
Jul 21, 11:02 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
ExcessDan |
|
29. |
Jul 21, 11:04 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
Flood |
|
30. |
Jul 21, 11:05 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
ExcessDan |
|
37. |
Jul 21, 11:18 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
Redwood |
|
38. |
Jul 21, 11:21 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
Hollow Man |
|
153. |
Jul 21, 19:31 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
Stinky_Toe |
|
159. |
Jul 21, 19:40 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
daSmirnov |
|
28. |
Jul 21, 11:04 |
Re: Thoughts? |
Hump |
|
34. |
Jul 21, 11:13 |
Re: Thoughts? |
WebDemon |
|
39. |
Jul 21, 11:23 |
Re: Thoughts? |
nin |
|
76. |
Jul 21, 13:23 |
Re: Thoughts? |
alnya |
|
78. |
Jul 21, 13:29 |
Re: Thoughts? |
ExcessDan |
|
79. |
Jul 21, 13:30 |
Re: Thoughts? |
Flood |
|
80. |
Jul 21, 13:33 |
Re: Thoughts? |
alnya |
|
81. |
Jul 21, 13:44 |
Re: Thoughts? |
nin |
|
86. |
Jul 21, 13:56 |
Re: Thoughts? |
alnya |
|
31. |
Jul 21, 11:07 |
No subject |
space captain |
|
33. |
Jul 21, 11:12 |
Re: No subject |
ExcessDan |
|
36. |
Jul 21, 11:17 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
32. |
Jul 21, 11:08 |
Too bad |
VampiricuS |
|
35. |
Jul 21, 11:13 |
Re: Too bad |
DDI |
|
40. |
Jul 21, 11:26 |
fuck off |
space captain |
|
41. |
Jul 21, 11:29 |
Re: fuck off |
WebDemon |
|
60. |
Jul 21, 12:28 |
Re: fuck off |
a |
|
42. |
Jul 21, 11:30 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
space captain |
|
48. |
Jul 21, 11:54 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
sinner's saint |
|
49. |
Jul 21, 11:56 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
BFSoLo. |
|
50. |
Jul 21, 11:57 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
WebDemon |
|
43. |
Jul 21, 11:31 |
duhhhhhhhhh |
space captain |
|
44. |
Jul 21, 11:35 |
Re: duhhhhhhhhh |
WebDemon |
|
45. |
Jul 21, 11:40 |
Re: duhhhhhhhhh |
space captain |
|
46. |
Jul 21, 11:50 |
Funny |
Mad Midnight Bomber |
|
47. |
Jul 21, 11:54 |
nIn |
runnerct32 |
|
51. |
Jul 21, 11:58 |
No subject |
space captain |
|
53. |
Jul 21, 12:09 |
Re: No subject |
MMORPGHoD |
|
52. |
Jul 21, 12:02 |
Re: No subject |
Rockn-Roll |
|
54. |
Jul 21, 12:12 |
Music penis... |
Ronin |
|
56. |
Jul 21, 12:15 |
Re: No subject |
Ronin |
|
55. |
Jul 21, 12:13 |
Re: Engines |
Dread |
|
57. |
Jul 21, 12:19 |
Now for my actual comment... |
Ronin |
|
58. |
Jul 21, 12:25 |
Re: Now for my actual comment... |
S_DOG34 |
|
59. |
Jul 21, 12:28 |
Re: Now for my actual comment... |
Satyric0n |
|
63. |
Jul 21, 12:32 |
Re: Now for my actual comment... |
S_DOG34 |
|
64. |
Jul 21, 12:36 |
Re: Now for my actual comment... |
Rebian |
|
65. |
Jul 21, 12:39 |
26 year old Sound Engineer |
Taulin |
|
73. |
Jul 21, 13:15 |
Re: Now for my actual comment... |
Kangzai |
|
61. |
Jul 21, 12:29 |
Re: Reznor on DOOM 3 |
FuriousBroccoli |
|
62. |
Jul 21, 12:31 |
Re: Reznor on DOOM 3 |
Ronin |
|
66. |
Jul 21, 12:45 |
Re: No subject |
space captain |
|
67. |
Jul 21, 12:48 |
Re: No subject |
Satyric0n |
|
69. |
Jul 21, 12:58 |
Re: No subject |
Zathrus |
|
70. |
Jul 21, 13:05 |
Re: No subject |
Bosanac |
|
71. |
Jul 21, 13:09 |
Re: No subject |
ExcessDan |
|
72. |
Jul 21, 13:14 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
68. |
Jul 21, 12:50 |
Re: No subject |
ExcessDan |
|
74. |
Jul 21, 13:16 |
Re: No subject |
Taulin |
|
75. |
Jul 21, 13:23 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
83. |
Jul 21, 13:46 |
Re: No subject |
sinner's saint |
|
84. |
Jul 21, 13:47 |
Caps? |
Gervaise |
|
87. |
Jul 21, 14:03 |
Re: Caps? |
Halsy |
|
93. |
Jul 21, 14:14 |
Re: Caps? |
MMORPGHoD |
|
88. |
Jul 21, 14:07 |
Re: Engines |
space captain |
|
89. |
Jul 21, 14:10 |
Re: Engines |
Satyric0n |
|
91. |
Jul 21, 14:12 |
Re: Engines |
Tuna |
|
94. |
Jul 21, 14:15 |
Re: Engines |
space captain |
|
95. |
Jul 21, 14:15 |
Re: Engines |
heroin |
|
96. |
Jul 21, 14:16 |
Re: Engines |
WebDemon |
|
105. |
Jul 21, 14:29 |
Re: Engines |
ExcessDan |
|
90. |
Jul 21, 14:11 |
Re: Out if the Blue |
space captain |
|
92. |
Jul 21, 14:13 |
No subject |
space captain |
|
97. |
Jul 21, 14:17 |
Re: No subject |
Bosanac |
|
98. |
Jul 21, 14:20 |
Re: No subject |
LoonBB |
|
99. |
Jul 21, 14:21 |
Re: No subject |
LoonBB |
|
100. |
Jul 21, 14:23 |
Re: Engines |
WebDemon |
|
102. |
Jul 21, 14:24 |
Re: Engines |
Bronco |
|
103. |
Jul 21, 14:25 |
Re: Engines |
WebDemon |
|
101. |
Jul 21, 14:24 |
Re: No subject |
Overon |
|
104. |
Jul 21, 14:28 |
No subject |
space captain |
|
107. |
Jul 21, 14:33 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
108. |
Jul 21, 14:38 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
110. |
Jul 21, 14:40 |
Re: No subject |
ExcessDan |
|
112. |
Jul 21, 14:58 |
Re: No subject |
SmyTTor |
|
113. |
Jul 21, 14:59 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
116. |
Jul 21, 15:05 |
Re: No subject |
MMORPGHoD |
|
118. |
Jul 21, 15:10 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
120. |
Jul 21, 15:12 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
149. |
Jul 21, 19:13 |
Re: No subject |
Beamer |
|
150. |
Jul 21, 19:17 |
Re: No subject |
heroin |
|
151. |
Jul 21, 19:24 |
Re: No subject |
Beamer |
|
152. |
Jul 21, 19:30 |
Is the answer .... |
Kosumo |
|
157. |
Jul 21, 19:38 |
Re: No subject |
heroin |
|
158. |
Jul 21, 19:38 |
Re: No subject |
Corn Wizard |
|
160. |
Jul 21, 19:40 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
119. |
Jul 21, 15:10 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
111. |
Jul 21, 14:49 |
Re: No subject |
heroin |
|
106. |
Jul 21, 14:31 |
Re: Razer Viper |
space captain |
|
114. |
Jul 21, 15:01 |
Re: Razer Viper |
WebDemon |
|
109. |
Jul 21, 14:40 |
Re: Thoughts? |
SMT |
|
115. |
Jul 21, 15:03 |
Music |
PsycSui |
|
117. |
Jul 21, 15:09 |
Re: No subject |
cecilkorik |
|
121. |
Jul 21, 15:23 |
Re: I can't wait |
space captain |
|
122. |
Jul 21, 15:29 |
Re: I can't wait |
SmyTTor |
|
123. |
Jul 21, 15:33 |
Re: I can't wait |
WebDemon |
|
124. |
Jul 21, 15:43 |
Re: I can't wait |
SmyTTor |
|
126. |
Jul 21, 15:47 |
Re: I can't wait |
Gandhi |
|
161. |
Jul 21, 20:04 |
Re: I can't wait |
Stinky_Toe |
|
162. |
Jul 21, 20:11 |
Re: I can't wait |
Corn Wizard |
|
163. |
Jul 21, 20:18 |
Re: I can't wait |
alnya |
|
125. |
Jul 21, 15:46 |
Wow |
Earthworm |
|
127. |
Jul 21, 15:53 |
No subject |
space captain |
|
128. |
Jul 21, 15:57 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
129. |
Jul 21, 15:57 |
Re: No subject |
Satyric0n |
|
130. |
Jul 21, 15:58 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
131. |
Jul 21, 15:59 |
Space Captian |
bigp3rm1 |
|
132. |
Jul 21, 16:03 |
still goin |
space captain |
|
133. |
Jul 21, 16:05 |
Re: still goin |
WebDemon |
|
137. |
Jul 21, 16:24 |
Re: still goin |
Propagandhi |
|
168. |
Jul 21, 20:35 |
Re: still goin |
Stinky_Toe |
|
177. |
Jul 21, 21:50 |
Re: still goin |
Gandhi |
|
138. |
Jul 21, 16:26 |
Re: still goin |
Propagandhi |
|
134. |
Jul 21, 16:10 |
No subject |
space captain |
|
148. |
Jul 21, 19:11 |
Re: No subject |
trgThrash |
|
135. |
Jul 21, 16:14 |
Hoodie Hoo |
SMT |
|
136. |
Jul 21, 16:16 |
No subject |
space captain |
|
139. |
Jul 21, 16:35 |
No subject |
space captain |
>> |
140. |
Jul 21, 17:56 |
Re: No subject |
S_DOG34 |
|
143. |
Jul 21, 18:10 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
144. |
Jul 21, 18:14 |
Re: No subject |
WebDemon |
|
146. |
Jul 21, 18:41 |
Re: No subject |
Corn Wizard |
|
141. |
Jul 21, 18:03 |
So, how about that... |
SMT |
|
142. |
Jul 21, 18:07 |
No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
145. |
Jul 21, 18:38 |
My God. |
NotOneOfUs |
|
147. |
Jul 21, 18:51 |
Woah... |
NotOneOfUs |
|
154. |
Jul 21, 19:32 |
Re: Good luck... |
Animals for Crackers |
|
155. |
Jul 21, 19:35 |
Re: Good luck... |
trgThrash |
|
156. |
Jul 21, 19:36 |
Re: No subject |
sir |
|
164. |
Jul 21, 20:22 |
Re: No subject |
WarPig |
|
167. |
Jul 21, 20:27 |
Re: No subject |
WarPig |
|
170. |
Jul 21, 21:04 |
Re: No subject |
Stinky_Toe |
|
181. |
Jul 21, 21:58 |
Re: No subject |
runnerct32 |
|
165. |
Jul 21, 20:26 |
Re: WOOT! |
Rseman |
|
166. |
Jul 21, 20:27 |
Re: WOOT! |
Rseman |
|
169. |
Jul 21, 20:39 |
Re: WOOT! |
WarPig |
|
171. |
Jul 21, 21:04 |
Re: WOOT! |
Beamer |
|
172. |
Jul 21, 21:09 |
Re: WOOT! |
cycle |
|
173. |
Jul 21, 21:17 |
WTF! |
Brick |
|
174. |
Jul 21, 21:27 |
Re: WTF! |
WarPig |
|
175. |
Jul 21, 21:40 |
Re: WTF! |
Bronco |
|
183. |
Jul 21, 22:23 |
Re: WTF! |
WarPig |
|
185. |
Jul 21, 22:26 |
Re: WTF! |
nin |
|
189. |
Jul 21, 23:45 |
Re: WTF! |
Fanatic |
|
184. |
Jul 21, 22:26 |
Re: WTF! |
Ray Marden |
|
176. |
Jul 21, 21:43 |
Did someone say benchmarks? |
Bronco |
|
178. |
Jul 21, 21:51 |
Re: Did someone say benchmarks? |
gulo |
|
179. |
Jul 21, 21:52 |
Re: Did someone say benchmarks? |
indiv |
|
182. |
Jul 21, 22:20 |
Re: Did someone say benchmarks? |
Ray Marden |
|
191. |
Jul 21, 23:49 |
Re: Did someone say benchmarks? |
TheNarcis |
|
180. |
Jul 21, 21:54 |
Re: No subject |
gulo |
|
186. |
Jul 21, 22:45 |
Re: No subject |
rkone |
|
187. |
Jul 21, 23:06 |
Re: No subject |
gulo |
|
188. |
Jul 21, 23:42 |
Re: No subject |
jm0ris0n |
|
190. |
Jul 21, 23:47 |
Re: No subject |
Lactose The Intolerant |
|
192. |
Jul 22, 00:07 |
Gulo... |
NotOneOfUs |
|
193. |
Jul 22, 00:24 |
Re: Gulo... |
gulo |
|
194. |
Jul 22, 01:52 |
Re: Gulo... |
NotOneOfUs |
|
238. |
Jul 22, 17:23 |
Re: Gulo... |
gulo |
|
195. |
Jul 22, 05:50 |
Re: Steering Wheel Support. Hello? |
KilrathiAce |
|
196. |
Jul 22, 12:45 |
wasting time |
Dalumberjack |
|
197. |
Jul 22, 13:51 |
The official... |
Ray Marden |
|
203. |
Jul 22, 14:11 |
Re: The official... |
Gandhi |
|
216. |
Jul 22, 14:39 |
Re: The official... |
Ray Marden |
|
217. |
Jul 22, 14:45 |
Re: The official... |
jm0ris0n |
|
218. |
Jul 22, 14:46 |
Re: The official... |
jm0ris0n |
|
219. |
Jul 22, 14:50 |
Re: The official... |
Ray Marden |
|
220. |
Jul 22, 14:52 |
Re: The official... |
jm0ris0n |
|
221. |
Jul 22, 14:53 |
Re: The official... |
Dalumberjack |
|
222. |
Jul 22, 15:34 |
Re: The official... |
jm0ris0n |
|
223. |
Jul 22, 15:38 |
Re: The official... |
Ray Marden |
|
224. |
Jul 22, 15:49 |
Re: The official... |
Furious |
|
225. |
Jul 22, 16:10 |
Re: The official... |
Ray Marden |
|
226. |
Jul 22, 16:16 |
Re: The official... |
Gandhi |
|
227. |
Jul 22, 16:19 |
Re: The official... |
Bronco |
|
228. |
Jul 22, 16:23 |
Re: The official... |
BFSoLo. |
|
229. |
Jul 22, 16:26 |
Re: The official... |
BFSoLo. |
|
198. |
Jul 22, 13:52 |
No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
199. |
Jul 22, 14:04 |
Re: No subject |
jm0ris0n |
|
200. |
Jul 22, 14:07 |
Ice Ice Baby |
Furious |
|
208. |
Jul 22, 14:16 |
Re: Ice Ice Baby |
Ray Marden |
|
201. |
Jul 22, 14:08 |
Re: No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
202. |
Jul 22, 14:10 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
205. |
Jul 22, 14:13 |
Re: No subject |
jm0ris0n |
|
209. |
Jul 22, 14:17 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
210. |
Jul 22, 14:19 |
Re: No subject |
jm0ris0n |
|
213. |
Jul 22, 14:20 |
Re: No subject |
jm0ris0n |
|
214. |
Jul 22, 14:23 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
204. |
Jul 22, 14:12 |
Re: No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
206. |
Jul 22, 14:14 |
Re: No subject |
jm0ris0n |
|
207. |
Jul 22, 14:15 |
No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
211. |
Jul 22, 14:20 |
No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
212. |
Jul 22, 14:20 |
No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
215. |
Jul 22, 14:26 |
No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
230. |
Jul 22, 16:28 |
Re: No subject |
Capella |
|
231. |
Jul 22, 16:36 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
233. |
Jul 22, 16:45 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
234. |
Jul 22, 16:54 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
236. |
Jul 22, 16:56 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
237. |
Jul 22, 17:08 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
239. |
Jul 22, 19:18 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
240. |
Jul 22, 19:36 |
Re: No subject |
WarPig |
|
241. |
Jul 22, 19:51 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
242. |
Jul 22, 20:03 |
Re: No subject |
WarPig |
|
244. |
Jul 22, 20:31 |
Crank up da phat beatz on Doom 3 |
Celestial Toad |
|
243. |
Jul 22, 20:28 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
248. |
Jul 23, 01:14 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
249. |
Jul 23, 01:25 |
Re: No subject |
Sixis |
|
252. |
Jul 23, 08:27 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
253. |
Jul 23, 08:39 |
Re: No subject |
Ray Marden |
|
235. |
Jul 22, 16:56 |
Re: No subject |
Capella |
|
245. |
Jul 22, 20:32 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
246. |
Jul 22, 20:49 |
Re: No subject |
Capella |
|
250. |
Jul 23, 08:22 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
247. |
Jul 22, 20:52 |
Re: No subject |
WarPig |
|
251. |
Jul 23, 08:24 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
254. |
Jul 23, 20:02 |
Re: No subject |
Corn Wizard |
|
255. |
Jul 25, 04:00 |
Re: No subject |
Taulin |
|
256. |
Jul 25, 09:44 |
Re: No subject |
Isus_in_Black. |
|
258. |
Jul 26, 11:32 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
259. |
Jul 26, 12:46 |
Re: No subject |
Taulin |
|
260. |
Jul 26, 17:56 |
Re: No subject |
Gandhi |
|
261. |
Jul 26, 21:08 |
Re: No subject |
Bronco |
|
232. |
Jul 22, 16:40 |
Re: gfx |
MonteCristo |
|
257. |
Jul 26, 01:27 |
No subject |
Dalumberjack |
|
262. |
Jul 27, 21:53 |
Re: No subject |
Tanto Edge |
|
|
|