Reznor on DOOM 3

A Q&A on nine inch nails access (thanks Not One Of Us) offers Trent Reznor's take on why he did not end up working on the DOOM 3 soundtrack as planned. Here's the deal on what happened, and Trent's guess about who ended up doing the theme song:
john carmack and i had established a friendship while working on quake. he came to see up playing during the last tour and wanted to get my feelings on a remake of doom with a new advanced engine he was working on. we discussed how cool it would be to create a place that was immersive to the point it wouldn't need a "soundtrack" -- the technology was advanced enough to visually and aurally to create a rich environment you could truly explore and inhabit. we discussed my involvement as the overall sound producer -- from foley and voice over to ambient world noise.

later, i started work on what would be used at the e3 show 2 years ago. it was exciting working in a totally new way with new tools. i was working directly in the game editor and with the programmers refining the sound code and helping the environment come alive. tried "tuning" various environmental sound sources so they'd cohesively interact with on another in a "musical" way. the advanced technology provided enough horsepower to give me a seemingly limitless amount of freedom. it was a lot of work, a lot of thinking in a different way, and a lot of fun. i was working with the best guys in the field -- true geniuses.

out idea was to have no music, apart from a main theme i'd write for the intro. no rock, nothing current sounding, nothing to date the game.

well... eventually time and money and bad management came into play and it didn't work out. disappointing on a number of levels for me, but that's the way it went.

I have seen the engine at work and it is great. i'm looking forward to seeing what they've done with the game.

and i guess tool did the theme song
View : : :
93.
 
Re: Caps?
Jul 21, 2004, 14:14
93.
Re: Caps? Jul 21, 2004, 14:14
Jul 21, 2004, 14:14
 
He should also ditch that junky typewriter he keeps using.

After reading that site, I now realize that people who type in CAPS are to be cherished, for the world could be much, much worse.
This comment was edited on Jul 21, 14:19.
Date
Subject
Author
1.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
2.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
3.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
4.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
5.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
11.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: No subject
13.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
      Re: No subject
21.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
       Re: oh my
6.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
7.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: No subject
77.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
82.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
85.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
8.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
9.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
10.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
12.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
15.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
14.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
16.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
17.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
22.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
25.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
18.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
19.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
20.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
23.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
24.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
26.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
27.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
29.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
30.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
37.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
38.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
153.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
159.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
28.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
34.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
39.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
76.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
78.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
79.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
80.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: Thoughts?
81.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
86.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: Thoughts?
31.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
33.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
36.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
32.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
35.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
40.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
41.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
60.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
42.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
48.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
49.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
50.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
43.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
44.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
45.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
46.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
47.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
51.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
53.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
52.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
54.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
56.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
55.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
57.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
58.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
59.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
63.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
64.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
65.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
73.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
61.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
62.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
66.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
67.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
69.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
70.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
71.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
72.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: No subject
68.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
74.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
75.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
83.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
84.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
87.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
 93.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
  Re: Caps?
88.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
89.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
91.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
94.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
95.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
96.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
105.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
90.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
92.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
97.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
98.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
99.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
100.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
102.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
103.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
101.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
104.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
107.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
108.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
110.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
112.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
113.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
116.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
118.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: No subject
120.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
      Re: No subject
149.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
       Re: No subject
150.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
        Re: No subject
151.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
         Re: No subject
152.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
          Is the answer ....
157.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
          Re: No subject
158.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
        Re: No subject
160.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
         Re: No subject
119.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: No subject
111.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
106.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
114.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
109.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
115.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
117.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
121.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
122.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
123.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
124.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
126.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
161.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
162.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
163.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
125.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
127.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
128.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
129.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
130.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
131.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
132.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
133.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
137.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
168.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
177.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
138.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
134.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
148.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
135.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
136.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
139.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
140.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
143.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
144.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
146.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
141.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
142.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
145.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
147.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
154.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
155.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
156.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
164.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
167.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
170.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
181.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
165.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
166.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
169.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
171.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
172.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
173.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
174.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
175.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
183.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
   Re: WTF!
185.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
    Re: WTF!
189.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
     Re: WTF!
184.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
176.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
178.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
179.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
182.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
191.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
180.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
186.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
187.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
188.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
190.
Jul 21, 2004Jul 21 2004
192.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
193.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
194.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
238.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
    Re: Gulo...
195.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
196.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
197.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
203.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
216.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
217.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
218.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
219.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
220.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
221.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
222.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
223.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
       Re: The official...
224.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
        Re: The official...
225.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
         Re: The official...
226.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
          Re: The official...
227.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
        Re: The official...
228.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
         Re: The official...
229.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
          Re: The official...
198.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
199.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
200.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
208.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
201.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
202.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
205.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
209.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
210.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
213.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
     Re: No subject
214.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
     Re: No subject
204.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
206.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
207.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
211.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
212.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
215.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
230.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
231.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
233.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
234.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
236.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
237.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
     Re: No subject
239.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
      Re: No subject
240.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
       Re: No subject
241.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
        Re: No subject
242.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
         Re: No subject
244.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
243.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
248.
Jul 23, 2004Jul 23 2004
249.
Jul 23, 2004Jul 23 2004
     Re: No subject
252.
Jul 23, 2004Jul 23 2004
     Re: No subject
253.
Jul 23, 2004Jul 23 2004
      Re: No subject
235.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
245.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
246.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
250.
Jul 23, 2004Jul 23 2004
     Re: No subject
247.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
251.
Jul 23, 2004Jul 23 2004
     Re: No subject
254.
Jul 23, 2004Jul 23 2004
      Re: No subject
255.
Jul 25, 2004Jul 25 2004
       Re: No subject
256.
Jul 25, 2004Jul 25 2004
        Re: No subject
258.
Jul 26, 2004Jul 26 2004
         Re: No subject
259.
Jul 26, 2004Jul 26 2004
          Re: No subject
260.
Jul 26, 2004Jul 26 2004
           Re: No subject
261.
Jul 26, 2004Jul 26 2004
           Re: No subject
232.
Jul 22, 2004Jul 22 2004
257.
Jul 26, 2004Jul 26 2004
262.
Jul 27, 2004Jul 27 2004