Any jerk who thinks UT 2004 is a good game should not be reviewing an Old West Game. Duh, Spanish accents in the game? Where did this person think real cowboys were from? Hollywood?
Only time will tell if that holds true. People may play a game for awhile, but if they join a community they are less likely to leave. I personally am thoroughly enjoying CoH, but I don't see myself playing it for multiple years unless the expansions are excellent.
So many other games to play right now too...so my gaming is spread among about 5 games and 3 mods on top of that.