People don't like the new Star Wars movies because it's full of bad, dry acting. There is absolutely no emotion apart from anakin's whining in episode 2. George Lucas hasn't directed in so long, he forgets how.
About the Revolutions - my cousin tells me(he rented the DVD from a store that puts new releases out a week early) the special features were pretty slim. No commentary track was the biggest problem I remember him saying. I think I will wait for a special edition. I'm happy to buy two version of the LOTR movies normal and Extended, just because I love them so much. Revolutions didn't leave an excellent impression when I left the theatre, so I can wait. But, I'll check it out when I'm in the store buying Texas Chainsaw, just incase he overlooked some things
"The only downside to being better than everyone else is that people tend to assume you're pretentious."