Since i was introduced to Doom as my first shooter then that's the game i have fond memories of. Before that i only experienced what the Atari 800 offered

If i played wolf then i guess Doom would have been only an incremental step up in graphics (z axis movement) better textures,models etc.. Unreal 2 certainly didn't capture the "spirit" of the first one. One issue that bothers me is the total lack of new shooters ala Hexen and Heretic and Wheel of Time. I like shooting machine guns as much as the next person but it's a cool feeling when you can place spells on baddies or your friends by turning them into sheep or the ability to fly for a certain duration
I like old dusty castles and creatures with strange abilities. Unreal 1 had castles AND space textures but still managed to intrigue simply cuz the graphics were so good. Generally, the two locales don't mix very well in single player. I really liked RTCW, the castles didn't seem to be out of place, in fact, i feel it added to the atmosphere.
<wasp>