Re: OotB: Happy Holiday?
Oct 14, 2024, 21:05
Beamer wrote on Oct 14, 2024, 20:55:
I think part of the issue is we need to define "indigenous people."
Fortunately, it's the first paragraph on Wikipedia:
There is no generally accepted definition of Indigenous peoples, although in the 21st century the focus has been on self-identification, cultural difference from other groups in a state, a special relationship with their traditional territory, and an experience of subjugation and discrimination under a dominant cultural model.
While you can argue that native americans aren't the only indigenous people of the Americas, I don't think it's possible to say that the term doesn't apply to them under this definition.
It's worth noting that it isn't "Native American's Day." "Indigenous People" is a broader term.
His point really isn't about the definition or meaning of "indigenous", even though that's what this started out as.
Rather his point is, regardless of what you call the indigenous in America, they should only be treated exactly the same as non-indigenous, just as every other citizen (though that citizenship was only granted in 1924 for USA, and 1956 for Canada), historical context be damned ... because if we took historical context into account, then what about all this <gestures at all of human history>.
1.
Oct 14, 12:35Oct 14 12:35
3.
Oct 14, 13:33Oct 14 13:33
4.
Oct 14, 14:38Oct 14 14:38
5.
Oct 14, 14:53Oct 14 14:53
6.
Oct 14, 14:59Oct 14 14:59
11.
Oct 14, 17:55Oct 14 17:55
12.
Oct 14, 18:19Oct 14 18:19
13.
Oct 14, 18:41Oct 14 18:41
15.
Oct 14, 18:52Oct 14 18:52
17.
Oct 14, 18:56Oct 14 18:56
18.
Oct 14, 18:58Oct 14 18:58
19.
Oct 14, 19:27Oct 14 19:27
23.
Oct 14, 19:51Oct 14 19:51
24.
Oct 14, 19:52Oct 14 19:52
30.
Oct 14, 20:11Oct 14 20:11
40.
Oct 14, 20:47Oct 14 20:47
21.
Oct 14, 19:39Oct 14 19:39
22.
Oct 14, 19:48Oct 14 19:48
25.
Oct 14, 20:01Oct 14 20:01
29.
Oct 14, 20:10Oct 14 20:10
31.
Oct 14, 20:12Oct 14 20:12
32.
Oct 14, 20:15Oct 14 20:15
33.
Oct 14, 20:20Oct 14 20:20
34.
Oct 14, 20:23Oct 14 20:23
35.
Oct 14, 20:27Oct 14 20:27
36.
Oct 14, 20:29Oct 14 20:29
37.
Oct 14, 20:30Oct 14 20:30
27.
Oct 14, 20:02Oct 14 20:02
28.
Oct 14, 20:05Oct 14 20:05
38.
Oct 14, 20:32Oct 14 20:32
39.
Oct 14, 20:39Oct 14 20:39
41.
Oct 14, 20:48Oct 14 20:48
42.
Oct 14, 20:53Oct 14 20:53
43.
Oct 14, 20:55Oct 14 20:55
44.
Oct 14, 20:59Oct 14 20:59
45.
Oct 14, 21:02Oct 14 21:02
46.
Oct 14, 21:05Oct 14 21:05
Re: OotB: Happy Holiday?
47.
Oct 14, 21:33Oct 14 21:33
48.
Oct 14, 21:40Oct 14 21:40
64.
Oct 15, 07:06Oct 15 07:06
68.
Oct 15, 13:02Oct 15 13:02
49.
Oct 14, 21:40Oct 14 21:40
50.
Oct 14, 21:41Oct 14 21:41
51.
Oct 14, 22:14Oct 14 22:14
52.
Oct 14, 22:15Oct 14 22:15
53.
Oct 14, 22:17Oct 14 22:17
54.
Oct 14, 22:18Oct 14 22:18
55.
Oct 14, 22:20Oct 14 22:20
56.
Oct 14, 22:21Oct 14 22:21
58.
Oct 14, 23:14Oct 14 23:14
59.
Oct 14, 23:43Oct 14 23:43
26.
Oct 14, 20:01Oct 14 20:01
14.
Oct 14, 18:49Oct 14 18:49
16.
Oct 14, 18:53Oct 14 18:53
2.
Oct 14, 12:51Oct 14 12:51
7.
Oct 14, 15:00Oct 14 15:00
8.
Oct 14, 15:41Oct 14 15:41
9.
Oct 14, 16:41Oct 14 16:41
10.
Oct 14, 16:56Oct 14 16:56
20.
Oct 14, 19:35Oct 14 19:35
57.
Oct 14, 23:01Oct 14 23:01
60.
Oct 14, 23:50Oct 14 23:50
61.
Oct 14, 23:53Oct 14 23:53
62.
Oct 15, 04:25Oct 15 04:25
63.
Oct 15, 07:01Oct 15 07:01
69.
Oct 15, 13:06Oct 15 13:06
70.
Oct 15, 13:47Oct 15 13:47
71.
Oct 15, 21:05Oct 15 21:05
72.
Oct 16, 01:37Oct 16 01:37
65.
Oct 15, 08:53Oct 15 08:53
66.
Oct 15, 09:01Oct 15 09:01
67.
Oct 15, 12:31Oct 15 12:31