55.
 
Re: Morning Metaverse
Jan 12, 2021, 17:43
Tomas
 
55.
Re: Morning Metaverse Jan 12, 2021, 17:43
Jan 12, 2021, 17:43
 Tomas
 
Cutter wrote on Jan 11, 2021, 23:51:
Tomas, you're conflating personal censorship and legal censorship. When your parents tell you not to swear, yes, that is technically censorship but it's not at all the same thing as being forbidden protected speech under penalty of law. One gets you grounded for the weekend the other sends you to prison illegally.

Parler's business model is one of, ostensibly, 'free speech'. Well too bad for them that no one told them that there's no such thing as "free speech" in America. There is only, and has only ever been, "protected speech" in America. And with protected speech there are limits to what you can say, and potential legal liability for the things you say. In short you're allowed to criticize things you don't like but you are not entitled to a platform to dispense those criticisms either. Otherwise I could call your employer and tell them you're a pedophile and you'd have no legal recourse to do anything whether it was true or not. And do you really believe for even one second that anyone should be able to say whatever they like no matter how fucking crazy or hateful or illegal it is?

All these companies that have refused to have anything to do with Parler owe them nothing legally or morally. They have no responsibility or obligation to them in any way, shape, or form. And not a single one of them is stopping Parler from doing business or limiting their protected speech. Them refusing to do business with Parler is not a violation of their protected-speech. That's no different from you coming into my restaurant dressed as Hitler and telling me I have no choice but to serve you. Really? So where do my rights come in to it? See, if that happens, I point to the sign by the entrance as I'm escorting you from the premises, "The Management Reserves The Right To Refuse Service". I don't have to give you a reason why. I don't want on you on my property so out you go. Your rights end where mine begin. Feel free to stand on the sidewalk and cry about it all you like, your rights haven't been violated. You need to learn a little something about law.

Uhm, no I'm not conflating them. The fact that censorship can come from multiple sources was my exact point. I am bothered when people make up definitions for words that aren't accurate, like suggesting that what AWS and others did was not censorship. I suppose we could imagine that their basis for doing what they did may not have been to censor what was taking place, I mean, that goes against what they have publically stated, but regardless of all that, and irrespective of the correctness or legality of it, censorship occurred. Unless I'm mistaken, I've also never stated that I think they were wrong in doing so. My argument has been about how this affects things from here on out as our society and technology evolve (including how we communicate as humans).

In regards to the rest of your post, I agree with it. I'm not sure what I've said to convince you otherwise. It is starting to feel like you aren't even reading my posts. My point has been and still is that there is a change in technology and with it there should be some discussion regarding how that is affecting a great number of things including, but not exclusively our first amendment rights. I'm under no false impression that we have complete freedom of speech, nor have I ever stated such.

Edit: lost my temper today. Embarrassing, but I'll survive.

This comment was edited on Jan 12, 2021, 22:33.
Date
Subject
Author
1.
Jan 11, 12:26Jan 11 12:26
2.
Jan 11, 12:30Jan 11 12:30
3.
Jan 11, 12:31Jan 11 12:31
4.
Jan 11, 12:39Jan 11 12:39
5.
Jan 11, 13:05Jan 11 13:05
6.
Jan 11, 13:56Jan 11 13:56
7.
Jan 11, 14:10Jan 11 14:10
10.
Jan 11, 14:21Jan 11 14:21
9.
Jan 11, 14:19Jan 11 14:19
12.
Jan 11, 15:00Jan 11 15:00
14.
Jan 11, 15:08Jan 11 15:08
19.
Jan 11, 15:45Jan 11 15:45
20.
Jan 11, 15:56Jan 11 15:56
       Re: Morning Metaverse
29.
Jan 11, 16:36Jan 11 16:36
        Re: Morning Metaverse
31.
Jan 11, 16:45Jan 11 16:45
         Re: Morning Metaverse
32.
Jan 11, 16:52Jan 11 16:52
          Re: Morning Metaverse
34.
Jan 11, 16:58Jan 11 16:58
           Re: Morning Metaverse
36.
Jan 11, 17:09Jan 11 17:09
            Re: Morning Metaverse
38.
Jan 11, 17:18Jan 11 17:18
             Re: Morning Metaverse
46.
Jan 11, 18:05Jan 11 18:05
             Re: Morning Metaverse
40.
Jan 11, 17:33Jan 11 17:33
            Re: Morning Metaverse
37.
Jan 11, 17:17Jan 11 17:17
           Re: Morning Metaverse
42.
Jan 11, 17:56Jan 11 17:56
            Re: Morning Metaverse
41.
Jan 11, 17:34Jan 11 17:34
           Re: Morning Metaverse
44.
Jan 11, 18:01Jan 11 18:01
            Re: Morning Metaverse
15.
Jan 11, 15:08Jan 11 15:08
26.
Jan 11, 16:25Jan 11 16:25
16.
Jan 11, 15:23Jan 11 15:23
17.
Jan 11, 15:28Jan 11 15:28
24.
Jan 11, 16:21Jan 11 16:21
30.
Jan 11, 16:44Jan 11 16:44
48.
Jan 11, 22:00Jan 11 22:00
       Re: Morning Metaverse
11.
Jan 11, 14:22Jan 11 14:22
13.
Jan 11, 15:04Jan 11 15:04
21.
Jan 11, 15:59Jan 11 15:59
18.
Jan 11, 15:36Jan 11 15:36
35.
Jan 11, 17:02Jan 11 17:02
8.
Jan 11, 14:10Jan 11 14:10
22.
Jan 11, 16:10Jan 11 16:10
23.
Jan 11, 16:17Jan 11 16:17
27.
Jan 11, 16:28Jan 11 16:28
47.
Jan 11, 20:26Jan 11 20:26
25.
Jan 11, 16:22Jan 11 16:22
28.
Jan 11, 16:29Jan 11 16:29
33.
Jan 11, 16:54Jan 11 16:54
39.
Jan 11, 17:19Jan 11 17:19
43.
Jan 11, 18:00Jan 11 18:00
45.
Jan 11, 18:01Jan 11 18:01
49.
Jan 11, 23:51Jan 11 23:51
 55.
Jan 12, 17:43Jan 12 17:43
 Re: Morning Metaverse
50.
Jan 12, 03:49Jan 12 03:49
52.
Jan 12, 08:36Jan 12 08:36
53.
Jan 12, 09:43Jan 12 09:43
54.
Jan 12, 10:46Jan 12 10:46
51.
Jan 12, 07:19Jan 12 07:19