Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
User Settings
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Germany 08/31
Chicago, IL USA, IL 10/19

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed - SimCityís launch woes: Another nail in the DRM coffin, a red flag for games reviewers.
Many games sites, including this one, were offered access to a review event where SimCity could be played in a controlled environment prior to launch. Many sites (although not this one, for reasons detailed here) published their reviews based on these events or, in some cases, on additional playtime on specific dedicated review servers. Some sites waited, played on the live servers ó or tried to! ó and then published their reviews. Thatís fine ó after all, what other options are there?

High-profile site Polygon initially gave the game a glowing 9.5 out of 10. Then, they knocked it down to 8. Then, they knocked it down to 4. Thereís a collective gasp from the crowd. A four out of ten! Thatís a genuinely bad score! That ainít no seven.

No. Itís not. And it doesnít matter, because Metacritic ó which is the only reason publishers actually care about review scores ó never alters a score, once itís been published. So the Metacritic entry for SimCity from Polygon still stands at Ď95í. In fact, according to Metacritic, the critical consensus is sitting at a nice, healthy, 81. The servers could catch fire tomorrow, EA could shut down the servers, fire everyone at Maxis and flood the entire office with venomous snakes, and the Metacritic score would remain unchanged forever. Bonuses for everybody! Or not, as the case may be.

Meanwhile, the average user score is 1.7. Out of ten. Is anybody surprised?

20. Re: Op Ed Mar 8, 2013, 13:01 Ozmodan
You have to wonder how many times will people continue to let EA screw them over. I just don't buy EA games anymore. Problem solved.  
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
    Date Subject Author
  1. Mar 8, 09:13 Re: Op Ed Verno
  2. Mar 8, 09:14 Re: Op Ed ASeven
  4. Mar 8, 09:29  Re: Op Ed InBlack
  6. Mar 8, 09:31   Re: Op Ed ASeven
  12. Mar 8, 11:19    Re: Op Ed Creston
  25. Mar 8, 14:33     removed RollinThundr
  7. Mar 8, 09:34   Re: Op Ed Verno
  8. Mar 8, 09:38    Re: Op Ed ASeven
  9. Mar 8, 09:41    Re: Op Ed InBlack
  10. Mar 8, 10:09  Re: More Big Picture Details HorrorScope
  21. Mar 8, 13:25  Re: Op Ed Tumbler
  23. Mar 8, 13:53   Re: Op Ed Creston
  24. Mar 8, 14:29    Re: Op Ed Beamer
  28. Mar 8, 15:56     Re: Op Ed Beamer
  29. Mar 8, 16:02   Re: Op Ed jdreyer
  30. Mar 8, 16:04    Re: Op Ed nin
  31. Mar 8, 16:59     Re: Op Ed Creston
  32. Mar 8, 17:22      Re: Op Ed Julio
  3. Mar 8, 09:25 Re: Op Ed Verno
  5. Mar 8, 09:29  Re: Op Ed ASeven
  11. Mar 8, 10:31 Re: Op Ed Silicon Avatar
  13. Mar 8, 11:29 Re: Op Ed Jivaro
  15. Mar 8, 12:10  Re: Op Ed gilly775
  16. Mar 8, 12:18   Re: Op Ed Jivaro
  22. Mar 8, 13:30   Re: Op Ed Tumbler
  18. Mar 8, 12:52  Re: Op Ed Creston
  14. Mar 8, 12:06 Re: Op Ed NegaDeath
  17. Mar 8, 12:24 Re: Op Ed saluk
  19. Mar 8, 13:00 Re: Op Ed Cutter
>> 20. Mar 8, 13:01 Re: Op Ed Ozmodan
  26. Mar 8, 15:20 Re: Op Ed Tim Collins
  27. Mar 8, 15:41  Re: Op Ed Verno


Blue's News logo