Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
User Settings
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Germany 08/31
Chicago, IL USA, IL 10/19

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed - Game Theory- Making Room for the Women.
Unfortunately this rise in so-called casual play has upset some of those who see themselves as guardians of the true flame. There’s been a definite backlash against the idea that women are entering the hallowed citadel, dropping in a few scatter cushions and ending all the fun. Particular ire is reserved for anyone who dares to point out that female characters in games are often unsupported in the bra region for no apparent reason; given boring, bland supporting roles; and totally absent.

56. Re: Op Ed Dec 28, 2012, 09:18 Slashman
Draugr wrote on Dec 28, 2012, 00:01:
You're anecdote boils down to 'I don't think women really are into games because when I went to LAN parties I think one of the women only played because of her boyfriend, and the other two I don't consider good enough to be real gamers'...Strange how bad players at LAN parties who have penises aren't written off in such a fashion. No one questions them about being 'real gamers' they're just shitty players.

The other two(one of whom is a good friend of mine) were basically there because they were friends with the group of us who played games together. Neither of them played much outside of LAN parties. Certainly neither of them invested into gaming systems or even bought games with the rest of us.

I think it's silly to take an anecdote as evidence alone, which you're basically doing. The very fact that your anecdote has 3 women in it kind of proves the point that there are women who play these kind of games. Certainly it is a male dominated hobby, but they aren't just conjured up or only there to play because of a man as you and others seem to imply. I mean there were three examples in your story, but you focused on the woman who was there because of her boyfriend, the only one of the three that reinforced your argument.

Well here's some more anecdotal evidence for you. I've been a computer tech and IT admin for 17 years and have the opportunity to see thousands of systems as they come into our workshop for repairs. I have yet to see a system belonging to a woman come in with games like those that weren't installed by her kids or boyfriend. And more often than not, they want them uninstalled. But maybe all those women are too embarrassed about the fact that they play Dawn of War and Counterstrike, so they blame it on their kids and husbands.

If I told a story about how there were no black people at the LAN parties I attended growing up, and therefore it leads me to believe that black people aren't into video games (or aren't into the same video games as white people,) I think you'd consider that pretty absurd. This is what you're asking us to do with your anecdote.

If you grew up in a predominantly white neighborhood, then even though I'd say your argument was flawed(and you were probably overly sheltered), I'd at least understand why you made it. However, we aren't talking about a specific ethnicity that is concentrated in a specific region, we are talking about a gender that's pretty much everywhere(unless you're a monk living in a male-only monastery). Women actually outnumber men where I live.

There are also probably more female players that play the kind of games you say they don't than you'd think. You play hundreds of faceless people when you play online, some of those people are going to be women. Obviously you'd be none the wiser unless you asked.

Except I do ask quite often. As I said, I see thousands of computers belonging to all sorts of people due to my job. Generally when I find games on them, I ask who installed them because a lot of people get upset over the fact that their kids are using their PCs for games.

I'm not saying that women gamers who play those games dont' exist at all. I'm just saying that I seriously doubt that their numbers are very high. I can totally believe that they flourish in the casual market. I just don't think that the numbers for more traditional hardcore games are there.

Because some people would prefer things to change, and do what they can to affect it instead of just keeping their head down. The consolation prize I guess, is people like yourself who don't want to play halo because of toxic environment can reap the benefits. As you said you don't play these games for the very reasons she is talking about them anyway, so if this is really where the focus is I don't see why you would be concerned.

I don't have an issue with people wanting to change XBox Live(and goodluck trying to correct bad parenting from the internet side). My issue is that all these articles lump all aspects of gaming into the same boat as if XBox Live represents every gaming community for every genre of game ever made. If there is a problem with behavior on XBox Live, then fine. That doesn't mean that the community for Endless Space has the same problem. Or that the community for Tribes Ascend has the same problem.

Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
    Date Subject Author
  1. Dec 26, 12:49 Re: Op Ed StingingVelvet
  37. Dec 27, 11:04  Re: Op Ed Beamer
  2. Dec 26, 12:55 Re: Op Ed Eirikrautha
  3. Dec 26, 13:00 Re: Op Ed Cutter
  4. Dec 26, 13:06  Re: Op Ed Overon
  5. Dec 26, 13:43   Re: Op Ed Burrito of Peace
  6. Dec 26, 14:22    Re: Op Ed RollinThundr
  8. Dec 26, 14:52     Re: Op Ed Draugr
  9. Dec 26, 14:59      Re: Op Ed Mashiki Amiketo
  12. Dec 26, 15:40     Re: Op Ed Overon
  13. Dec 26, 15:48      Re: Op Ed FloorPie
  15. Dec 26, 16:10       Re: Op Ed Draugr
  18. Dec 26, 16:55        STOP THE MADNESS!!! SlimRam
  19. Dec 26, 17:03         Re: STOP THE MADNESS!!! The Half Elf
  20. Dec 26, 17:08         Re: STOP THE MADNESS!!! Cutter
  21. Dec 26, 18:52          Re: STOP THE MADNESS!!! Yosemite Sam
  24. Dec 26, 19:41           Re: STOP THE MADNESS!!! Draugr
  26. Dec 26, 20:13          Re: STOP THE MADNESS!!! RollinThundr
  27. Dec 26, 20:50           Re: STOP THE MADNESS!!! cappy
  29. Dec 26, 21:29            Re: STOP THE MADNESS!!! nin
  25. Dec 26, 20:05      Re: Op Ed Eirikrautha
  28. Dec 26, 20:50       Re: Op Ed Overon
  30. Dec 26, 21:29        Re: Op Ed Slashman
  31. Dec 27, 02:01         Re: Op Ed Overon
  40. Dec 27, 12:51          Re: Op Ed Slashman
  45. Dec 27, 16:57           Re: Op Ed Overon
  46. Dec 27, 17:12            Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  48. Dec 27, 17:35             Re: Op Ed panbient
  52. Dec 28, 01:47              Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  53. Dec 28, 07:01               Re: Op Ed panbient
  54. Dec 28, 07:30                Re: Op Ed Beamer
  57. Dec 28, 22:13                Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  49. Dec 27, 18:28            Re: Op Ed Slashman
  51. Dec 28, 00:01             Re: Op Ed Draugr
  55. Dec 28, 08:19              Re: Op Ed RollinThundr
>> 56. Dec 28, 09:18              Re: Op Ed Slashman
  33. Dec 27, 05:04      Re: Op Ed Prez
  7. Dec 26, 14:50   Re: Op Ed Draugr
  17. Dec 26, 16:42    Re: Op Ed Kobalt
  22. Dec 26, 19:09     Re: Op Ed Draugr
  39. Dec 27, 11:23   Re: Op Ed MindStalker3
  10. Dec 26, 15:18 Re: Op Ed Creston
  14. Dec 26, 16:01  Re: Op Ed eRe4s3r
  11. Dec 26, 15:23 Re: Op Ed entr0py
  16. Dec 26, 16:25 Re: Op Ed Cutter
  23. Dec 26, 19:12 Re: Op Ed jdreyer
  32. Dec 27, 02:07 Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  34. Dec 27, 05:07  Re: Op Ed Julio
  35. Dec 27, 06:01   Re: Op Ed InBlack
  41. Dec 27, 15:30   Re: Op Ed Draugr
  42. Dec 27, 16:08    Re: Op Ed RollinThundr
  43. Dec 27, 16:51     Re: Op Ed Overon
  44. Dec 27, 16:55      Re: Op Ed nin
  47. Dec 27, 17:13       Re: Op Ed Overon
  50. Dec 27, 20:59      Re: Op Ed jdreyer
  36. Dec 27, 10:02 Re: Op Ed Bludd
  38. Dec 27, 11:07  Re: Op Ed Beamer


Blue's News logo