Out of the Blue

I saw a reference today to Indiana Jones today that made me think of Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, a recollection not as painful for me as it should be, as I have not seen the much-reviled latest installment in the series. This is because, as I've mentioned in the past, MrsBlue and I end up seeing a vast majority of movies after they come to cable/satellite, especially when the reviews are as mixed (to put it kindly) as they were for Indy 4. Which brings me to my point: Is Spielberg so embarrassed by this film he's keeping it off cable? It was released well over four years ago, and its absence from the small screen is starting to seem like the it's getting The Star Wars Holiday Special treatment. By all accounts this is deserved, but I remain masochistically curious to see it.

Masochistic Links: Thanks Ant and Acleacius.
Play: Siegius Arena.
Stories: Florida man accused of returning used enemas. Thanks Gawker.
Seattle police seek more drones while two sit unused. Thanks Slashdot.
Science: Satellite Left Stranded by SpaceX Rocket Falls From Space.
Media: Minecraft Environmentalists.
The Onion Takes on TED.
This guy is awesome at kicking American footballs.
Follow-up: Brevity.
View : : :
42.
 
Re: Out of the Blue
Oct 14, 2012, 12:48
42.
Re: Out of the Blue Oct 14, 2012, 12:48
Oct 14, 2012, 12:48
 
Prez wrote on Oct 14, 2012, 12:34:
Anyone who has ever enjoyed a sci-fi film has swallowed truckloads of insanely impossible stuff on the way, but now all of a sudden we need constant impeccable believability?

There's a concept known as "suspension of disbelief". What a good movie does is allow you to maintain that. What a bad movie does is constantly assault it. Promotheus did the latter. The problem is that people are focusing on single issues, and arguing that they aren't that big a deal. Granted, within the scope of a large movie, a single incident isn't enough to break suspension of disbelief. But what Prometheus had was a pattern of stupidity. If you've got a movie that focuses on a bunch of supposedly intelligent people, and you have them continuously make stupid decisions, that's more than sufficient to break suspension of disbelief.

If you take, say, Aliens (I remember it better than Alien), were there stupid things happening? Yup. But was it out of character? Nope. The majority of characters were "space marines", they weren't expected to be scientists, so it's not surprising that they made decisions that were questionable.

Note that suspension of disbelief doesn't just apply to sci-fi, it applies to every genre. It's one of the reasons that quite a few modern horror movies are considered "bad" - because the characters make decisions that are completely unrealistic. Prometheus had the problem that they had a direction they wanted the movie to go, but apparently they couldn't figure out how to get it there without all the mistakes taking place. It's a good indication they needed to work on the script a lot more. What could have been at least a good movie turned out to be, well, pretty bad.
Date
Subject
Author
1.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
2.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
4.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
3.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
5.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
6.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
7.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
9.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
13.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
14.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
17.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
20.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
11.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
12.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
16.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
21.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
25.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
26.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
       Re: Out of the Blue
27.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
        Re: Out of the Blue
28.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
         Re: Out of the Blue
29.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
          Re: Out of the Blue
30.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
           Re: Out of the Blue
46.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
            Re: Out of the Blue
31.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
       Re: Out of the Blue
34.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
        Re: Out of the Blue
32.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
       Re: Out of the Blue
33.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
        Re: Out of the Blue
35.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
         Re: Out of the Blue
36.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
          Re: Out of the Blue
38.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
           Re: Out of the Blue
47.
Oct 15, 2012Oct 15 2012
        Re: Out of the Blue
8.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
10.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
15.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
18.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
19.
Oct 13, 2012Oct 13 2012
22.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
23.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
24.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
37.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
39.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
40.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
41.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
 42.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
    Re: Out of the Blue
43.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
44.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
45.
Oct 14, 2012Oct 14 2012
49.
Nov 11, 2012Nov 11 2012
48.
Oct 15, 2012Oct 15 2012