Minecraft Patent Lawsuit

A tweet by Minecraft creator and Mojang founder Markus "Notch" Persson reveals that Mojang is being sued for patent infringement over Minecraft, saying: "Step 1: Wake up. Step 2: Check email. Step 3: See we're being sued for patent infringement. Step 4: Smile." He's posted the complaint in Adobe Acrobat format, and Boing Boing notes the plaintiff in this case, Uniloc calls itself an intellectual property "incubation lab" specializing in computer security, but they just call them patent trolls, noting that the suit was filed in Tyler, Texas, which besides being the birthplace of NFL legend Earl Campbell, is apparently also renowned as a place where the courts are known to friendly to the plaintiffs in such cases.

Here's word from the complaint: "Mojang is directly infringing one or more claims of the ’067 patent in this judicial district ... by or through making, using, offering for sale, selling and/or importing Android based applications for use on cellular phones and/or tablet devices that require communication with a server to perform a license check to prevent the unauthorized use of said application, including, but not limited to, Mindcraft [sic]."

For his part, Notch tweets about his resolve to fight this out in court, just as he did when sued over the right to name his next game scrolls, saying: "Unfortunately for them, they're suing us over a software patent. If needed, I will throw piles of money at making sure they don't get a cent." He also blogs about this, giving his outlook on such litigation. Here's a portion:
But there is no way in hell you can convince me that it’s beneficial for society to not share ideas. Ideas are free. They improve on old things, make them better, and this results in all of society being better. Sharing ideas is how we improve.

A common argument for patents is that inventors won’t invent unless they can protect their ideas. The problem with this argument is that patents apply even if the infringer came up with the idea independently. If the idea is that easy to think of, why do we need to reward the person who happened to be first?

I will say that there are areas which are very costly to research, but where the benefits for mankind long term are very positive. I would personally prefer it to have those be government funded (like with CERN or NASA) and patent free as opposed to what’s happening with medicine, but I do understand why some people thing patents are good in these areas.

Trivial patents, such as for software, are counterproductive (they slown down technical advancement), evil (they sacrifice baby goats to baal), and costly (companies get tied up in pointless lawsuits).
View : : :
9.
 
Re: Minecraft Patent Lawsuit
Jul 22, 2012, 16:38
9.
Re: Minecraft Patent Lawsuit Jul 22, 2012, 16:38
Jul 22, 2012, 16:38
 
Notch may be in the right, but his smug approach makes me want him to fail. The "I'll throw piles of money at them!" is little more than a boast. It isn't "cool" and it doesn't put him in a "good guy" light.
Date
Subject
Author
1.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
2.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
3.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
55.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
4.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
5.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
41.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
44.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
45.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
46.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
64.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
6.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
7.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
8.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
 9.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
Re: Minecraft Patent Lawsuit
10.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
11.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
13.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
14.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
18.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
19.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
21.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
    removed
22.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
38.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
     removed
43.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
47.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
48.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
50.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
51.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
          Re: Minecraft Patent Lawsuit
29.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
39.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
40.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
42.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
27.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
31.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
12.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
15.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
16.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
32.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
17.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
20.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
23.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
24.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
26.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
28.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
34.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
35.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
25.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
66.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
52.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
30.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
33.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
36.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
37.
Jul 22, 2012Jul 22 2012
49.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
53.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
54.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
56.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
57.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
58.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
59.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
60.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
61.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
63.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
62.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012
65.
Jul 23, 2012Jul 23 2012