Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
User Settings
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Germany 08/31
Chicago, IL USA, IL 10/19

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

GamesIndustry International - Fez, Fish and The Problem with Patching.
Fez has grossed over a million dollars, and even after Microsoft has taken a lump of that, it would be outright negligent and irresponsible of Fish not to have money left over to cover an unforeseen problem like a reissued patch. Catch-22. If you're able to complain about it, you're also able to pay for it, and your users are quite entitled to excoriate you for using them as hostages in a debate with Microsoft which is of no real relevance to them.

"I don't care how indie you are, or how free and loose your ideas of commerce and creativity may be - once you've taken a million bucks from consumers, professionalism isn't optional" Equally, though, one can have sympathy with Microsoft. The company gives one patch for free, and charges for subsequent patches - not because it's greedy and avaricious (it does lots of other things for those reasons, of course), but because it doesn't want to see XBLA games being released buggy or incomplete and patched repeatedly. The Xbox is a console, and players expect not to be confronted with the kind of endless match of bugs and patches which so often afflict PC games. Microsoft has a duty to its consumers to try to enforce that, and ultimately, Fish bears responsibility for creating a patch with such a serious bug in it.

21. Re: Op Ed Jul 21, 2012, 21:15 Jerykk
Zyrxil wrote on Jul 21, 2012, 20:54:
Silicon Avatar wrote on Jul 21, 2012, 17:28:
Eh... I dunno. If you only get 1 shot at a patch and you mess it up knowing that it is going to cost you to fix it you'd think that patch would be bullet-proof.

It is not like they have to test against a million different pieces of hardware like you do on PC.

I'm confused as to why the testing process didn't catch the bug in the first place though. Isn't that what they are paid to do? Seems like the error is mutual and he should get to put his patch back up free.

1- Modern games are super complex, even if they're not AAA titles. It's a gameplay bug, not a hardware related crash. It's not reasonable to think a game can be completely bug free.

2- MS Certification, AFAIK, is only to make sure your patch doesn't melt your console or cause crashes. Again, it's a gameplay bug, and there's certainly no way MS patch certification guys could check for that.

Part of the certification process is ensuring that saves do not get corrupted. That falls under MS's TCR checklist. However, MS allowed the bug to be waived because it was rare.
Avatar 20715
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
    Date Subject Author
  1. Jul 21, 13:30 Re: Op Ed [VG]Reagle
  2. Jul 21, 13:35  Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  3. Jul 21, 14:35   Re: Op Ed Draugr
  4. Jul 21, 15:05 Re: Op Ed Ozmodan
  5. Jul 21, 15:50  Re: Op Ed Beelzebud
  6. Jul 21, 16:07  Re: Op Ed Dmitri_M
  18. Jul 21, 20:34  Re: Op Ed briktal
  7. Jul 21, 16:22 Re: Op Ed Dev
  8. Jul 21, 16:50 Re: Op Ed 007Bistromath
  26. Jul 22, 01:03  Re: Op Ed Prez
  27. Jul 22, 01:06   Re: Op Ed Prez
  28. Jul 22, 01:13    Re: Op Ed PHJF
  29. Jul 22, 01:46     Re: Op Ed killer_roach
  9. Jul 21, 17:28 Re: Op Ed Silicon Avatar
  19. Jul 21, 20:54  Re: Op Ed Zyrxil
>> 21. Jul 21, 21:15   Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  30. Jul 22, 01:58  Re: Op Ed Devinoch
  31. Jul 22, 06:40   Re: Op Ed ChaosEngine
  10. Jul 21, 17:43 Re: Op Ed peteham
  11. Jul 21, 17:56  Re: Op Ed killer_roach
  12. Jul 21, 18:50   Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  13. Jul 21, 18:56    Re: Op Ed spindoctor
  14. Jul 21, 19:25    Re: Op Ed Beamer
  17. Jul 21, 20:16     Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  23. Jul 21, 23:55     Re: Op Ed Crustacean Soup
  15. Jul 21, 19:27 Re: Op Ed Mashiki Amiketo
  16. Jul 21, 19:33  Re: Op Ed ASeven
  20. Jul 21, 20:54   Re: Op Ed Mashiki Amiketo
  22. Jul 21, 21:29    Re: Op Ed ASeven
  24. Jul 22, 00:22     Re: Op Ed Mashiki Amiketo
  25. Jul 22, 00:30 Re: Op Ed SimplyMonk
  32. Jul 22, 11:08 Re: Op Ed Ray Marden
  33. Jul 22, 12:35  Re: Op Ed Overon
  34. Jul 22, 17:08  Re: Op Ed Mordecai Walfish
  35. Jul 22, 20:12  Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  36. Jul 25, 02:47 Re: Op Ed KilrathiAce


Blue's News logo