This game is polarizing. I see one of three comments when I read about this game. (paraphrasing of course)
1) It sucks! Sure, the person complaining might be specific about a certain area..like graphics for example...but the bottom line is that the overall experience is "sucky".
2) It is awesome! It tries to do something different, it isn't elves and orcs, and the lore is basically spilling out from everywhere you go. It has its rough spots, as any new MMO does, but it isn't the same old same old....and apparently...that makes it awesome.
3) Since everyone and their uncle from World of Warcraft didn't bail on Azeroth to go try the game out because it is not elves and orcs, and thus don't have an opinion, it must suck. I mean clearly, if all the other sheeple in the world haven't tried it, then nobody else should. er..right?
But in all seriousness, it is interesting how polarizing it is. Just in my small little piece of the world social network I have friends who agree on just about every game ever..and yet they can't even agree on the quality of the tutorial in Secret World...let alone the game as a whole.
I have gotten a guest pass of sorts that I will be giving a go round in the next few days...my curiosity is high. It might suck, it might be awesome...but I have to admit..there is a part of me that very much likes the idea that there is a MMO out there that didn't try to make a gameworld that strives to appeal to EVERYONE. It has a target audience and that is who they seem to be developing the game for...much like CCP has done with Eve. That doesn't mean I will like the game, but as rare as that is...I respect it. Do I still have to respect it if it sucks? lol