EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?

This document (Adobe Acrobat format) outlines a legal ruing in the EU that seems to open the door for resale of digitally distributed software (thanks Joao). Here's a bit:
Where the copyright holder makes available to his customer a copy – tangible or intangible – and at the same time concludes, in return form payment of a fee, a licence agreement granting the customer the right to use that copy for an unlimited period, that rightholder sells the copy to the customer and thus exhausts his exclusive distribution right. Such a transaction involves a transfer of the right of ownership of the copy. Therefore, even if the licence agreement prohibits a further transfer, the rightholder can no longer oppose the resale of that copy.
View : : :
19.
 
Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
Jul 3, 2012, 14:33
19.
Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales? Jul 3, 2012, 14:33
Jul 3, 2012, 14:33
 
Techie714 © wrote on Jul 3, 2012, 11:19:
This is the last thing business in the U.S. wants to see. EA & Valve have no interest in you reselling your games. Hell, the rumors are all around that the next consoles wont allow resale of games. I could be wrong though. It would open the door to new business models in the U.S.

Not entirely true. Publishers wouldn't mind people reselling their games if they didn't see it as a direct threat to their primary business model: selling new copies. Argue all you want about whether piracy affects the bottom line one way or the other, it is impossible to argue that the Gamestops of the world most certainly do insert themselves between a buyer with money and the publisher attempting to sell a new copy of the game they've paid to develop. Sure, it's great for the consumer, but it's lousey for the business of developing the product they like to consume.

Sad fact is that, unlike a physical good or product, there is no diminishing utility for digital media. The game I sell you is exactly the same experience and level of quality as the one you in turn sell to someone else, and someone else, and so on and so forth. There's no such thing as a high-mileage game. The storage media for a physical game may see wear, but when dealing with the actual data it's essentially immortal. The only consideration is 1) does it work and 2) is it cheaper than a new copy at retail price?

This business model of making and selling games is being forced to change. It was prodded in that direction long ago before any legal decisions upholding a consumer's right to resell their games. That's practically unenforceable whether it's legal or not. People will continue to trade, lend, sell, buy used, and pirate games whether it's legal or not and in all of those scenarios the publisher does not get a dime for the product they've paid to develop and put into the market. It is an unsustainable business that's become worse every day as more and more people start finding ways of getting their games cheaper or for free. The mass market has opted to not support the pre-exisiting business model and thus the business model will adapt to the market.

Ultimately, that changes the type of games made. We've already seen the move towards sequels, established franchises, and licensed games because it's a safer bet. It changes the quality of games as developers have struggled to meet the demands of increasing complexity on leaner, less risky budgets and timelines. And it fundamentally changes how games are distributed and monetized...which gives us things like more emphasis on micro-transactions, server-based accounts, and DLC.
Date
Subject
Author
15.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
3.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
4.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
26.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
 19.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
 Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
28.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
10.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
14.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
16.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
21.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
43.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
47.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
54.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
59.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
65.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
74.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
75.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
76.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
79.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
80.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
              Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
81.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
               Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
83.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
               Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
85.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
                Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
87.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
               Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
88.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
                Re: EU to Allow Digital Software Resales?
70.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
25.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
27.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
29.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
36.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
38.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
39.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
41.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
49.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
51.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
52.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
58.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
63.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
86.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
78.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
40.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
42.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
46.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
48.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
44.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
50.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
53.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
55.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
56.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
62.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
66.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
67.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
69.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
72.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
57.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
61.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
64.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
68.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
71.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
73.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
84.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
82.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
60.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
32.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
18.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
23.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
31.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
37.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
34.
Jul 3, 2012Jul 3 2012
91.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
93.
Jul 4, 2012Jul 4 2012
94.
Jul 5, 2012Jul 5 2012
95.
Jul 5, 2012Jul 5 2012
96.
Jul 5, 2012Jul 5 2012
98.
Jul 5, 2012Jul 5 2012
97.
Jul 5, 2012Jul 5 2012