Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
User Settings
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Germany 08/31
Chicago, IL USA, IL 10/19

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

HotHardware - If You Resell Your Used Games, The Terrorists Win. Thanks Ant via Slashdot.
Both Browne and Braben conflate hating GameStop (a thoroughly reasonable life choice) with the supposed evils of the used games market. Braben goes so far as to claim that used games are actually responsible for high game prices and that "prices would have come down long ago if the industry was getting a share of the resells." Amazingly, no game publishers have stepped forward to publicly pledge themselves to lower game prices in exchange for a cut of used game sales.

40. Re: Op Ed Apr 23, 2012, 23:15 Kabuto
Sepharo wrote on Apr 23, 2012, 20:29:
Kabuto wrote on Apr 23, 2012, 18:23:
Jerykk wrote on Apr 23, 2012, 12:30:

You're still arguing legality and not practical results. Once again, nobody is disputing that people are allowed to buy and sell used games. However, when used games are bought and sold, neither the developer or publisher sees compensation. Whether or not they deserve to see compensation is another matter entirely, but the fact remains that they don't see any. Same thing applies to piracy.

I see the problem here. You want to argue the single used game transaction and ignore the larger picture. You want to ignore that the original "new" buyer almost certainly factored in their ability to resell the game at a later time before making their purchase. You want to pretend that the money received by selling their game will not recirculate into the game industry and will only be used on preowned games. You want to ignore that each and every time a used copy of a game is sold it gives publishers the ability to up sell a new customer on high margin DLC. 
You have to take a pretty narrow point of view to equate piracy and used game sales.

Now you shall face my army of strawmen... Muwhahahaahah

Jerykk has made his position clear that he sees no difference between buying a used game or pirating a game because during the actual transaction (buying a used game or downloading a pirated game) no compensation is provided to the publisher and or developer. This position ignores any and all other factors that make buying a used game dramatically different than simply downloading a pirated copy. I pointed out a few of the differences to illustrate my point, which is hardly straw-man argument. 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
    Date Subject Author
  1. Apr 21, 16:35 Re: Op Ed CommunistHamster
  4. Apr 21, 19:19  Re: Op Ed Draugr
  2. Apr 21, 16:58 Re: Op Ed space captain
  3. Apr 21, 19:13 Re: Op Ed Dev
  5. Apr 21, 19:31  Re: Op Ed Draugr
  6. Apr 21, 20:06   Re: Op Ed NKD
  9. Apr 21, 23:04    Re: Op Ed Draugr
  10. Apr 21, 23:49    Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  14. Apr 22, 04:18     Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  17. Apr 22, 07:59      Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  25. Apr 23, 00:47       Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  26. Apr 23, 01:28        Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  27. Apr 23, 01:49         Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  28. Apr 23, 02:57          Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  30. Apr 23, 03:35           Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  32. Apr 23, 04:20            Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  33. Apr 23, 04:54             Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  34. Apr 23, 07:08              Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  37. Apr 23, 12:30               Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  38. Apr 23, 18:23                Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  39. Apr 23, 20:29                 Re: Op Ed Sepharo
>> 40. Apr 23, 23:15                  Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  41. Apr 24, 00:12                 Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  42. Apr 24, 01:56                  Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  44. Apr 24, 03:14                   Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  47. Apr 24, 03:35                    Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  49. Apr 24, 17:17                     Re: Op Ed Dev
  48. Apr 24, 05:28                    Re: Op Ed Kabuto
  51. Apr 25, 03:27                     Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  43. Apr 24, 03:08                Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  45. Apr 24, 03:21                 Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  46. Apr 24, 03:32                  Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  50. Apr 25, 03:09                   Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  52. Apr 25, 13:42                    Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  53. Apr 26, 01:27                     Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  35. Apr 23, 07:36              Re: Op Ed NKD
  36. Apr 23, 10:00               Re: Op Ed Beamer
  29. Apr 23, 03:07          Re: Op Ed PHJF
  23. Apr 22, 22:40      Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  24. Apr 23, 00:12       Re: Op Ed NKD
  31. Apr 23, 04:12        Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  13. Apr 22, 02:19    Re: Op Ed StingingVelvet
  15. Apr 22, 05:15    Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  18. Apr 22, 09:24    Re: Op Ed psulli
  19. Apr 22, 11:46     Re: Op Ed StingingVelvet
  21. Apr 22, 12:14     Re: Op Ed NKD
  22. Apr 22, 15:40     impressive! space captain
  7. Apr 21, 21:01 Re: Op Ed Ruffiana
  8. Apr 21, 22:11  ear against the wall space captain
  11. Apr 21, 23:51 letter to control about the big brother space captain
  12. Apr 22, 00:44  Re: letter to control about the big brother Agent.X7
  20. Apr 22, 11:55   Re: letter to control about the big brother Parallax Abstraction
  16. Apr 22, 06:27  Re: letter to control about the big brother Ruffiana


Blue's News logo