PropheT wrote on Apr 5, 2012, 19:41:
If you're willing to completely ignore the plot holes and to not think at all about what actually happened as a result of things that they'd established throughout the story of the game... I guess the ending could be fine (look, explosions! colors!). If you think about it at all, though?
Yes there are plot holes, but they're not as big as you think. The Normandy is not intact, but the portions that contain the crew are.
Making peace with the Quarians does not guarantee that no synthetic will EVER want to annihilate all organic life. As you can see throughout the series, the Geth have intelligence and change their motives just like any other species. The whole point of the Reapers is that they prune only the most advanced civilizations, in order to preserve organic life as a whole.
Finally, whether the fleet around earth was destroyed or not (I don't remember), the point is moot, because the important thing is that there are a significant amount of survivors remaining on their homeworld, which you saved.