Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - RSS Headlines   RSS Headlines   Twitter   Twitter

Op Ed

GameSpy - Should Diablo III have been first person?
I'll admit it. My first ever hands-on time with any Diablo game occurred just 24 hours ago, when my inexperienced Demon Hunter took his first fumbling steps into the Diablo III beta's dark and ominous dungeons. It took just three hours before I'd hacked and slashed my way to the main storyline's satisfying conclusion, but in that short period of time my eyes were opened to an entirely new perspective on a gaming world. As a lover of first person games, the isometric camera system in Diablo III felt very unfamiliar, and I inevitably wondered why Blizzard didn't make the leap to first person like so many other developers. This led me to wonder - should Diablo III have been a first person game, and what are the pros and cons of this approach? Let's find out.


47. Re: Op Ed Sep 23, 2011, 10:58 BurntSoul
yuastnav wrote on Sep 23, 2011, 08:52:

Something like nethack or dungeon crawl doesn't really work with coop.

Why? Can't we get creative and make it work?

First off I would never want Diablo III to be an FPS. However, I do think there is room for an FPS that has the Roguelike qualities of the diablo series as well as games like nethack/dungeon hack.

You probably already know this, but the Diablo series' roots were derived from the 'roguelike' game (random hack and slash + dungeon crawler adventure game, random loot drops). There are also multiplayer roguelike games. Go check the wiki on roguelikes to see it. Why is Diablo/Diablo II still being played today? I believe it's because of the Co-op, and the fact that the game is different enough based on random dungeon levels and item drops.

So why does this formula have to stay in the realm of isometric view?

There are more than a few FPS games right now that have everything Diablo has, excluding the level randomization. The story is generally the same: Kill bad guys + boss with quest, get loot, stay alive, level up and do it again.

FPS play + Randomization of levels and the options for them (before the game begins) are the only components that would need to be added.

What has to stay basically the same? The general storyline.

Future new campaigns could be created with new content, textures, creatures and tilesets - while the story changes with which baddies/bosses to kill. Alternatively, the original story could be retrofitted on the fly with a different tileset for that game (Kill boss A but now he lives in a dungeon as opposed to a castle, or he lives in the desert as opposed to the jungle).

You can also add randomly generated and/or recurring side-quests. MMORPGs do it all the time. Even if you didn't want that kind of randomization, you could create specific side-quests but randomly place them in the 'levels' when a new game starts or add more or less side-quests (or none at all).

This keeps things interesting and fresh.

You see, I'd rather be creative to solve this as opposed to saying it just cannot work.
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
    Date Subject Author
  1. Sep 22, 10:40 Re: Op Ed  nin 
  2. Sep 22, 10:47  Re: Op Ed Creston
  10. Sep 22, 11:27  Watter 
  12. Sep 22, 11:31   Re: Alamar
  13. Sep 22, 11:43    Re: Shok
  14. Sep 22, 11:48    Re:  nin 
  15. Sep 22, 11:53   Re: Bhruic
  18. Sep 22, 12:03    Re: Creston
  27. Sep 22, 13:46     Re: Bhruic
  16. Sep 22, 11:54  Re: Op Ed gilly775
  17. Sep 22, 11:58   Re: Op Ed  Darks 
  19. Sep 22, 12:24  Re: Op Ed Admgloval
  20. Sep 22, 12:37   Re: Op Ed  PHJF 
  22. Sep 22, 12:42    Re: Op Ed Creston
  41. Sep 22, 18:47    Re: Op Ed dangerman77
  42. Sep 22, 18:50     Re: Op Ed  Beamer 
  46. Sep 23, 10:15      Re: Op Ed BurntSoul
  26. Sep 22, 13:30   Re: Op Ed beigemore
  3. Sep 22, 10:52 Re: Op Ed space captain
  4. Sep 22, 11:00 Re: Op Ed Verno
  5. Sep 22, 11:01 Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  6. Sep 22, 11:03 Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  7. Sep 22, 11:06 Re: Op Ed  Cutter 
  8. Sep 22, 11:16  Re: Op Ed Mad Max RW
  9. Sep 22, 11:22 Re: Op Ed Alamar
  11. Sep 22, 11:30 Re: Game Reviews CommunistHamster
  21. Sep 22, 12:39 Re: Op Ed beigemore
  23. Sep 22, 13:08 Re: Op Ed Lobster
  24. Sep 22, 13:13  Re: Op Ed DG
  28. Sep 22, 15:06   Re: Op Ed  nin 
  30. Sep 22, 15:26    Re: Op Ed Creston
  25. Sep 22, 13:18 Re: Op Ed Red
  29. Sep 22, 15:21 Re: Op Ed Ruffiana
  31. Sep 22, 15:41 Re: Op Ed eunichron
  32. Sep 22, 15:58 Re: Op Ed Silicon Avatar
  33. Sep 22, 16:02 Re: Op Ed Creston
  34. Sep 22, 16:17  Re: Op Ed eunichron
  35. Sep 22, 16:20   Re: Op Ed  nin 
  36. Sep 22, 16:40    Re: Op Ed  Cutter 
  38. Sep 22, 16:51     Re: Op Ed  nin 
  40. Sep 22, 17:00      Re: Op Ed BurntSoul
  45. Sep 23, 08:52       Re: Op Ed yuastnav
>> 47. Sep 23, 10:58        Re: Op Ed BurntSoul
  48. Sep 23, 11:57         Re: Op Ed yuastnav
  49. Sep 23, 13:09          Re: Op Ed BurntSoul
  37. Sep 22, 16:48   Re: Op Ed Creston
  43. Sep 22, 19:54    Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  44. Sep 23, 04:06     Re: Op Ed InBlack
  39. Sep 22, 16:56 Re: Op Ed Jdrez