Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
User Settings
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Germany 08/31
Chicago, IL USA, IL 10/19

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

truepcgaming - Visual Noise: A Criticism of HUDs.
Having a playerís health, ammunition, inventory, and abilities always visible is a staple of the gaming medium, but one that we may be better off learning to deal without. I make this claim based solely on the experiences of noticing that virtually all games get better without an always-on interface. Iíve managed to nix 90% of the unnecessary HUD materials off New Vegas through two mods, and the result is a game that is unquestionably more immersive, balanced, difficult, and above all, beautiful.

18. Re: Op Ed Sep 17, 2011, 22:35 Rockn-Roll
That's not on's like saying removing stimulus improves immersion. Take that to the limit and it's like he's saying we would be more immersed with text based games! When the target is immersion then more stimulus is required in order to compensate for the fact that it's not real thus our own senses are hampered. Two senses are all we really have in a video game...sight and hearing...and even that input is heavily simulated.

In computer games we depend on the visual stimulus to replace the normal fact the more stimulus the more immersed we become. Now, if you cover up one of the stimuli with another one then it defeats the purpose of the first if you clutter the screen with inventory data then yeah it may be distraction, but it also adds more stimulus as long as the screen shows enough of the visuals. Heck...I'd go for an electric shock if my character gets electrocuted...some realizm goes a long way.

I just remembered that we had this same discussion when idsoftware added the damage face in Wolfenstein 3D. Some people thought it was obstructing their view and other thought it was cool ie. the technical details. But, what we learned later was that the visual indication of damage really helped the immersion level. But, id added a switch to turn it off...I think it's the people with small screens that have the problem...with lots of indicators and such their viewport shrinks from 17" down to like 15" and that's just too small for anything these days.

This comment was edited on Sep 18, 2011, 01:23.
Avatar 21182
Let's Rock!
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
    Date Subject Author
  1. Sep 17, 12:22 Re: Op Ed Cutter
  3. Sep 17, 12:37  Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  4. Sep 17, 14:01   Re: Op Ed Retired
  5. Sep 17, 14:01   Re: Op Ed [VG]Reagle
  6. Sep 17, 14:06    Re: Op Ed Retired
  28. Sep 18, 13:52     Re: Op Ed [VG]Reagle
  8. Sep 17, 15:11  Re: Op Ed Warskull
  2. Sep 17, 12:30 Re: Op Ed Creston
  7. Sep 17, 14:37 Re: Op Ed m0deth
  9. Sep 17, 16:14  Re: Op Ed nin
  10. Sep 17, 16:18   Re: Op Ed Beamer
  11. Sep 17, 17:07    Re: Op Ed PHJF
  14. Sep 17, 18:24     Re: Op Ed Beamer
  12. Sep 17, 17:49 Re: Op Ed Dev
  13. Sep 17, 17:57 Re: Op Ed Caladell
  15. Sep 17, 18:54 Re: Op Ed Ray Marden
  16. Sep 17, 20:13  Re: Op Ed J
  17. Sep 17, 20:48   Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  19. Sep 17, 22:37    Re: Op Ed Asmo
  20. Sep 18, 00:06     Re: Op Ed MisterBenn
>> 18. Sep 17, 22:35 Re: Op Ed Rockn-Roll
  21. Sep 18, 04:53 Re: Op Ed Crustacean Soup
  22. Sep 18, 07:47  Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  23. Sep 18, 09:16   Re: Op Ed eRe4s3r
  24. Sep 18, 10:01    Re: Op Ed Slashman
  25. Sep 18, 11:12    Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  26. Sep 18, 11:55     Re: Op Ed DaHauns
  27. Sep 18, 13:43    Re: Op Ed yuastnav
  30. Sep 19, 09:37     Re: Op Ed eRe4s3r
  29. Sep 18, 17:54   Re: Op Ed Crustacean Soup


Blue's News logo