I hate to break it to you, El Pit, but Jerykk is right.
As for Beamer, to ME it looks like you yourself don't understand your own motive why you're still posting in this topic. I think we all understand what you're saying, even with the multiple contradictions. One last thing to you: I'm kinda like StingingVelvet, in where I basically enjoy every solid, good game no matter what the genre. From all the games I've played in my life, Amnesia is by far the most scariest and it gave to me an experience that was new to me (never in my life did I cought myself holding my breath, grabbing my hard in a paranoid state thinking it'd shut off, etc). It was amazing. As one gamer to another I really recommend you to give it one last try. Just start up that game at night and play for an hour or so. I can hardly believe you won't get hooked.
As for Blue's topic... the devs brought this baby home, whether it's people's type of game or not. It'd be a damn shame if remaining in business isn't guaranteed.
Playing: Skyrim, World of Warcraft.
Future: Dead Space 3.