The Crew is a mixed bag for me and I’ve probably put 20 hours into it so far. I am a pretty big driving game fan starting in the old Xbox days and continuing today. I though the original Test Drive Unlimited was one of the slickest games to come out in a long time and the exploration side of things and the feel of just tooling along on the coast weaving in and out of traffic was sweet. It didn’t have the best handling with the Xbox wheel, but on my Xbox controller is rocked.
The good:
The Crew definitely has that cool TDU feel to it and definitely tickles the exploration itch. The “just drive around and admire the world” side of things is really well done too and I’ve spend hours just messing around in the world. The map and GPS stuff is very very similar to TDU as well and is easy to use and understand.
The bad:
Now onto the less than stellar side of things. The game doesn’t have to handle like Assetto Corsa to make me happy (and it’s doesn’t), but the handling is not quite as good as I would have liked. I am using a Logitech G27 and while serviceable, there is slop in the middle I don’t like that makes me feel like the wheel isn’t working at all until I turn enough for the force feedback to kick in again. It’s ok, but could be better. The clutch and H-Gate are done pretty well too though some cars have 7 gears and the shifter only goes to 6. I ended up switching to sequential shifting and it’s all good.
The force feedback is strange and overpowering when off-road and when hitting curbs. When off-road, I almost couldn’t handle the car at all and ended up tweaking my settings so that the in game FF is maxed and reduced the force to 60% in my Logitech Profiler. So the handling is ok, but not spectacular.
The gameplay:
The game itself is a mix of awesome and terrible. I mentioned the coolness of just driving and exploring but on the downside, the traffic isn’t so hot. The AI cars never switch lanes so you can barrel up the center lane or between lanes and almost never hit anything, making it less of a “plan your route through the next throng of traffic” thing and more of a “try not to drift outside this little corridor of space” thing. The latter can get a little difficult with the aforementioned slop in the wheel especially on the really high end exotics. Maybe this improves as I level up the cars but I haven’t seen anything yet. I’m still pretty low level though.
On the racing side of things, they are decent and the storyline is decent though a lot of the races are simple checkpoint races so far. The issue that I absolutely hate is the rubber-banding AI. It doesn’t matter how far behind they fall, they will catch up no problem when I slip up. It’s aggravating to know that I’ve driven the race almost perfectly and take the last corner really badly only for the #2 guy to be all over me. Additionally, when I screw up early in a race and expect to get last, I usually end up in first or second as they let me play catch up. It makes the racing part almost a deal breaker for me.
There are not a lot of cars to select from. I chose a starter Nissan 370Z and it’s fine but I am damn bored of it now and all the next cars I want to buy like the Corvette ZR1 and Ruf 3400K are too expensive. So 20 hours in the same car is weary. Plus the Viper SRT-10 is Uplay unlocked only so I have no idea when I’ll be able to get that ride. You need 100 Uplay points or whatever to unlock it.
Online:
It also sucks that the game is 100% online. Unlike TDU that you can still play to this day, when they shut down the Crew servers, you are done. Otherwise it’s ok. I’ve raced a couple of times in co-op and it’s neither here nor there. I had a couple of idiots try to grief but it’s super easy to quick travel to another location so they can’t do much. I don’t think I’ve ever seen more than 6 or 8 other players in a game with me, so it’s pretty limited in how many other players you see. I’d personally like to shut off all multiplayer, but that isn’t an option in game.