Cutter wrote on Apr 26, 2015, 11:16:
ASeven wrote on Apr 26, 2015, 10:49:
Aero wrote on Apr 26, 2015, 10:29:
I find lots of the uproar disappointing. Valve could be handling it better, but mostly what I hear (more elsewhere than here) is moaning from people who seem to feel entitled to other's peoples work.
This argument would be valid if mods hadn't been free these whole years and if the whole mod culture hadn't been founded in making mods for fun and NOT for profit.
I swear, most of the people who throw this stupid entitled argument are more often than not not modders. Not to mention each time someone uses the entitled word against consumers, they prove to be nothing more than idiotic mouthpieces of corporations that don't care for them. Useful idiots to sum them up.
But it's not because it's just not consumers but people in general, particularly the younger generations that feel self-entitled to everything under the sun. It's as if they should through life without ever being insulted or upset by anything.
And as it applies to consumerism it's no different. People deserve to paid for their work. That's a basic social tenet - time + labour = reward - unless they choose to volunteer it. Now, whether their work is considered to be actually worth anything at all is an entirely different matter. That's why the vast majority of people who think they're going to make a small fortune selling shit that would have otherwise been free are in for a rude awakening. It's why they have a donate button on Nexus, and why most people will choose that option on Steam.
It'll take a while to shake itself out and come back to equilibrium but it will. So relax and have a drink or something. No one is forcing anyone to do anything.
I wish I could share your optimism on this situation, I really do, but I think we both know full well that when you offer the promise of riches, or easy money, to a whole lot of people, in this case modders, in the long run everyone will be charging for their own mods. It's economical sense to do so in fact, why make a mod for free when you can charge for it and have people buy it, no matter how shitty it is? It's the factor of human greed I fear will destroy the modding scene and that's what's upsetting me a lot. I'm in my forties and have seen this scenario happen time and again so I know that once you introduce money into a system that sustained itself well without financial backing things change, drastically, for the worse, always.
In the long run it's economically illogical not to charge for mods and it's that scenario that worries me. If Valve had put a donate button instead of a buy button I would be totally for it but the way this has been implemented is the worst way it could have been.
Remember, people said that Greenlight and Early Access would also sort itself out and increase quality of the games that would be submitted to it and we know today that that isn't the truth. This is the same system, only with mods. It won't increase the quality of the mods, instead, much like Greenlight, it will open the door to a deluge of shitty mods, all trying to make a quick buck.
I just can't see this getting any better or coming back to an equilibrium, not unless there's a massive pushback.