Inevitably this thread will lead to Star Wars Ep3... So I'll start it. I liked it. I'm not diehard, but I am a SW fan. Obviously everyone will have their own ideas of what the movie should have been whats weird/wrong/inaccurate here and there. The main thing for me is that it was entertaining. Light sabres, space battles, explosions, light sabres, big armies, evil villians, the force, and light sabres.
My only gripe is that it felt rushed. There seems to have been enough material to make 2 movies. The events leading up to Annikan's ultimate turn to the dark side could have been fleshed out further to be more "gradual".
Anyone it was a fun movie, likely will see it again. Hope they eventually make more movies... Say 10 years from now?