kxmode wrote on Jul 20, 2010, 14:09:
I take issue when you say games like this aren't CRPGs. I'm an old school RPG gamer and I consider Mass Effect 1 and 2, Dragon Age, KOTOR, Fallout 3 and so forth all very fun RPGs. Let's look at what all of these that I would consider a CRPG:
1. They all have moral choices you must make.
2. They all have NPCs who react to things you do in the game.
3. Your character in all of them grow in power and abilities.
4. Your character is designed by you.
5. They all have highly developed story and setting.
6. They all task your character with saving the world (or universe if you played Mass Effect).
7. With the exception of Dragon Age Origins and Mass Effect 2 they all featured large worlds to explore.
It's probably pointless to weigh in on the "What makes a RPG a RPG" argument part 983028932, but based on the very limited information given, this 38 Studios game sounds like it'll lean more towards Diablo 2/Titan Quest than Baldur's Gate 2/DA:O, or Drakensang. Just my guess. This could be great however, I love TQ as much as I love what I consider to be more Bioware style rpgs.
Aside from that, your points are a bit generic, for the sake of argument one could say something like CoD:MW2 is almost an rpg by those standards. The GTA series also, or for that matter Saint's Row also fit into those eight points.
I am personally way more interested in games these days that allow you full control of a party, ala BG2, than whether or not they have a 'full open world' or any of the other nonsense that seems to force developers to design games with 1 controllable character.
More party based RPGs(of all descriptions) please, Game Developers!