THIS IS NOT JUST BASED ON SALES.
MOST OF YOU ARE FUCKING IDIOTS.
Erm, we know its not. But can you honestly say hand on heart sale figures aside that ratchet and clank should be above halo 3 regardless of what criterea its based on?
As of november ratchet and clank sales were at 74,500 with very mixed review scores (some as low as 75% and as high as 95% ). Whereas halo 3 has sold as of january 8.1 million copies with an average review score of easily into the high 90% mark, it almost doubled the amount of people playing on XBL overnight. So I can only assume that the ''700 anonymous (yeah I bet they are) Game Developer- and Gamasutra.com-reading industry professionals'' have miraculously ignored these figures and came up with their own views on what makes a good game - Essentially this list is not worth the paper its written on.
Ps. no im not a XB 'fanboi' or halo 3 lover, theres a few other games on their I could easily pick out on there for being retardedly placed.
This comment was edited on Mar 8, 13:02.