Geez, Kobulb, your posts used to be funny in a perverse kinda "how stoopid can this guy be?" kinda way, but now you're just plain boring.
Please refer to Zeph's post #94 as an example of a genuine discussion, and contrast it to your simplistic, contrarian diatribes. You're like the old Monty Python sketch - "You're not arguing with me, you're just contradicting everything I say!" "No, I'm not!".
Zeph, I have to admit I took you for a troll, too, at first, but your last post was well-written, if a bit long-winded. And it was actually on the freakin topic, which is more than I can say for my post!
Alls I can say is I've preordered Doom 3 and I'll make my decision on it AFTER I've played it. All this speculation, hypothesizin' and tangential discussion can be interesting while we await the release, but the proof of the game is in the playing.