BF1942 takes on more strategy than Tribes 2 with less complexity. It has resources (vehicle spawns) and player classes. Also, the vehicles drive much better.
Another thing Tribes 3 has going against it is bugs. The bugs in Tribes 2 were a joke. I've never seen a game patch itself to death before that one. Terrible product management and QA. It had a crumby interface, hard-to-navigate menus, the control wasn't as smooth as other FPS', and the vehicle controls were not intuitive.
Plus, the weapons sucked. I mean, who the hell wants a gun that shoots a spinning disk? In trying to be original, Tribes went with something stupid. Yes, we know every game has the Rocket Launcher, shotgun and sniper gun, but they do because those guns are the most fun. Spinning disks? Please.
I'm not sure exactly what game you're playing, but last time I checked, Tribes 2's vehicles were much more easy to control than those in BF1942. Menus? Tribes 2's menus were more than adequate, ESPECIALLY if you were to compare it to BF1942. The server browser is the best out there (that I have seen anyway), and the menu settings is set up like windows (start buton and all). I simply cannot fathom how you find that difficult to use. Tribes2's controls were VERY smooth, more smooth than most games that I've played (quake 3 aside). Granted, it has a steep learning curve, making it difficult to move at first, but once you actually sit down and play the game for more than 10 minutes, you understand how to make the controls work for you. It becomes second nature, and it gives you more freedom of movement than any other FPS out there.
I think you're makign things up to downplay this game.
I do agree that it was bug-ridden from the start, but they had fixed that. And besides, the sheer amount of lag that plagued BF1942 from the start made it just as undesirable for me. And talk about bad AI. But, they fixed BF1942, just like they did Tribes 2.
As per weapons, I completely disagree. Many of the tribes weapons are completely unoriginal, and they all have their own sort of personality and purpose. Unlike some games where you get a rocket launcher, a pistol, and 30 different machine guns. Tribes2 has classes, cool weapons, deployables, and fantastic, FAST, gameplay.
Oh, and it has disc-jumping