Man, I thought Max Payne was one of the greatest games ever released, I'm suprised so many people here don't give it more praise. I just got through playing it again, and while the SP was short and linear, it is a very very fun game. And to those who thought the writing was bad, what part of it was bad? I thought it was superb writing, especially with all of the clever metaphors in the dialog.
The graphics are nice, the engine is great, and the game is FUN. I played it twice through in the past couple of weeks again, and I really don't care if it is the same story line. I don't understand why people say that linear games don't have any replay value. I mean people love watching the same movies over and over; I think a select few games like Half-Life and Max Payne can be played over and over and still be just as fun.
And I really don't think bullet time is a gimmick - the game is very hard (on the harder diffuculty settings), and effective use of bullet time is essential (and fun!). Man I really wish gamers didn't have such pessimistic views about games all the time. Every thread on this site has some rant about "how much xxx game sucks," when (IMHO) they don't deserve it.