|
|
 |
| [Jan 07, 2009, 3:30 pm ET] - Share - Viewing Comments |
Greenspeak, the blog of one-time Computer Gaming World and Games
for Windows editor Jeff Green, offers a counterpoint to the story below, as
Jeff takes issue with Sam Kennedy's upbeat assessment of UGO's
acquisition of 1Up. He says Sam is, "in a horrid position here, having to put
a brave face on what is an unequivocally ugly mess. So I wish no ill-will on the
guy, and, more important, those following this story need to know that none of
this is his 'fault'. All this sh*t happened way above him. He's just trying to
make the best of a bad situation. And to that I offer him a heartfelt and
sincere good luck." Jeff goes through some of Sam's statements line-by-line,
sorting through what he considers spin, saying, "You're not the same 1UP because
you just lost a gigantic chunk of what made 1up 1up," and disbelieving that this
is the "best news" 1Up could have received, he says the following: "Again, no.
If this can be called 'the best news', I'd hate to see the bad news. In fact, it
might be the best bit of news that you and the others who kept their jobs ever
had, since you now don't have to be looking for work at the start of a new year,
in the worst economic climate this country has been in in the last 80 years."
 |
| 12. |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
Jan 7, 2009, 19:06 |
Creston |
|
|
Their podcasts and writing were anything but a "retyped version of Gamespot", considering they actually valued WRITING above all.
1UP didn't hire hardcore gamers that could write, they hired talented writers and personalities that also happened to play games.
I've never listened to their podcasts, so I'll take your word for it. But the "talented writers" part?
I don't read reviews to be entertained. I read reviews so I can find out whether the game is something I would like to play.
I found their reviews on average to be just as good / bad as most of the other ones. Their scores used to be lower than the big shill sites, but meh, I don't pay any attention to scores anyways.
Hey, if people are sad they're gone, fine, to each his own. I just don't see why everyone's all up in flames like the whole internet just fucking died.
Creston
This comment was edited on Jan 7, 2009, 19:18. |
|
 |
|
|
|
 |
|
| |
| |
|
Date |
Subject |
Author |
| |
1. |
Jan 7, 15:07 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
anime is great! |
| |
2. |
Jan 7, 15:23 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
the_culture |
| |
3. |
Jan 7, 15:26 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Kosumo |
| |
4. |
Jan 7, 15:40 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Wolfox |
| |
5. |
Jan 7, 16:12 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Kedyn |
| |
6. |
Jan 7, 16:19 |
Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
Creston |
| |
7. |
Jan 7, 16:28 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
Tumbler |
| |
8. |
Jan 7, 17:52 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
elefunk |
| |
9. |
Jan 7, 18:17 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
Kedyn |
| |
10. |
Jan 7, 18:26 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
CJ_Parker |
| |
11. |
Jan 7, 18:31 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
elefunk |
| |
13. |
Jan 7, 19:33 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
CJ_Parker |
| |
15. |
Jan 7, 19:50 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
elefunk |
| |
16. |
Jan 7, 20:06 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
ldonyo |
| |
17. |
Jan 7, 20:39 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
Prez |
| >> |
12. |
Jan 7, 19:06 |
Re: Maybe I'm just uber cynical |
Creston |
| |
14. |
Jan 7, 19:48 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
siapnar |
| |
18. |
Jan 7, 20:45 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Surf |
| |
19. |
Jan 7, 20:51 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Kxmode |
| |
20. |
Jan 7, 20:51 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
muttbunch |
| |
21. |
Jan 7, 20:57 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
| |
22. |
Jan 7, 21:09 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Prez |
| |
23. |
Jan 7, 21:32 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Surf |
| |
31. |
Jan 8, 06:55 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
zodden |
| |
24. |
Jan 7, 21:51 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
swaaye |
| |
25. |
Jan 7, 22:29 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
| |
26. |
Jan 7, 23:17 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
PHJF |
| |
28. |
Jan 8, 02:42 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Jerykk |
| |
29. |
Jan 8, 02:51 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
| |
35. |
Jan 9, 00:13 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Jerykk |
| |
36. |
Jan 9, 01:26 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
| |
37. |
Jan 9, 10:20 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Agent.X7 |
| |
38. |
Jan 9, 11:44 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Prez |
| |
39. |
Jan 9, 15:04 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
| |
41. |
Jan 9, 22:19 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Prez |
| |
42. |
Jan 10, 03:58 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
| |
43. |
Jan 10, 09:23 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Prez |
| |
44. |
Jan 10, 17:50 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
| |
45. |
Jan 10, 22:33 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Prez |
| |
40. |
Jan 9, 16:17 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
jdreyer |
| |
33. |
Jan 8, 13:56 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Bodolza |
| |
34. |
Jan 8, 14:17 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
jdreyer |
| |
27. |
Jan 7, 23:27 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
FuriousBroccoli |
| |
30. |
Jan 8, 02:54 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
Surf |
| |
32. |
Jan 8, 12:02 |
Re: Jeff Green on 1Up & UGO |
elefunk |
|
|
|