Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

BioShock Interview

Thinking BioShock From Tech to Philosophy converses with 2K Boston technical director Christopher Kline about their "terrible secret" (they're not actually located in Boston), as well less terrible topics, "such as getting gamers interested in seeing the sequel (and thus driving publisher interest) to the hard philosophies of technology use, UI design, and respect for the audience. "

View
3. Dumbing it down Aug 10, 2008, 08:45 Shadowcat
 
I'm saying, do you prefer to have a targeted, "These are the kind of players that we want," or do you want it to be truly, truly, "everyone can pick that up" type of game?

CK: Well, we want to sell our game to as many people as possible, because we don't believe that the game has to be brought down to any particular group of people; we believe that all gamers are intelligent, and all gamers want an exciting, mature, intellectual, and deep gaming experience.
If you happen to read this, Chris, I'd just like to point out that this is what people mean when they say you are "dumbing it down for console". The expression may be based upon stereotypes, but the point is that the notion that a game should be for everyone implies a lowest common denominator that you are explicitly pandering to.

You know that saying "You can please some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time"?

A truly great game is quite likely to be like the former. It probably won't be for everyone (because amazingly enough, different people like different things), but those who like it will LOVE it, and it will be remembered as a classic of its kind.

Your attitude will ultimately produce games fitting the second statement. It caters to everyone, but each person will only love it some of the time. These games might sell well, but will never be remembered as truly great, because almost everyone who plays it will be left thinking "if only..."

I'm not saying that it's not a valid business direction (although as a gamer it genuinely saddens me to see it happen), but it would be nice if you (and other people treading the same path) would accept that by going in this direction you absolutely are "dumbing it down".

This comment was edited on Aug 10, 08:46.
 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Aug 10, 01:50 No subject Donkey_Punch
  2. Aug 10, 06:15  Re: No subject Jerykk
  9. Aug 10, 14:25   Re: No subject Donkey_Punch
  6. Aug 10, 12:21  Re: No subject Ray Marden
>> 3. Aug 10, 08:45 Dumbing it down Shadowcat
  4. Aug 10, 09:03  Re: Dumbing it down The Half Elf
  10. Aug 10, 17:26   Re: Dumbing it down Shadowcat
  5. Aug 10, 09:30 No subject Wallshadows
  7. Aug 10, 13:34 BioShock jimnms
  8. Aug 10, 13:36 ... theyarecomingforyou
  11. Aug 10, 17:57  Re: ... Bilbo
  13. Aug 10, 20:31  Re: ... Jerykk
  15. Aug 10, 20:56   Re: ... the_culture
  17. Aug 10, 21:58    Re: ... Jerykk
  20. Aug 10, 22:59     Re: ... the_culture
  24. Aug 11, 00:00      Re: ... Jerykk
  27. Aug 11, 00:10       Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  28. Aug 11, 00:22        Re: ... Jerykk
  44. Aug 11, 11:40         Re: ... the_culture
  47. Aug 11, 11:55          Re: ... Jerykk
  49. Aug 11, 12:14           Re: ... the_culture
  56. Aug 11, 13:44            Re: ... Jerykk
  59. Aug 11, 14:00             Re: ... the_culture
  61. Aug 11, 14:10              Re: ... Jerykk
  62. Aug 11, 14:50               Re: ... Roachmojo
  63. Aug 11, 15:07                Re: ... Jerykk
  64. Aug 11, 15:07                Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  65. Aug 11, 15:25             Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  67. Aug 11, 21:56              Re: ... Beamer
  29. Aug 11, 00:27        Re: ... CreamyBlood
  12. Aug 10, 18:47 ... theyarecomingforyou
  14. Aug 10, 20:53  Re: ... the_culture
  16. Aug 10, 21:46   Re: ... CreamyBlood
  18. Aug 10, 22:11 ... theyarecomingforyou
  19. Aug 10, 22:59  Re: ... JohnBirshire
  21. Aug 10, 23:02   Re: ... the_culture
  22. Aug 10, 23:34    Re: ... Beamer
  26. Aug 11, 00:05  Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  23. Aug 10, 23:36 ... theyarecomingforyou
  25. Aug 11, 00:05  Re: ... Jerykk
  30. Aug 11, 00:56 ... theyarecomingforyou
  31. Aug 11, 01:16  Re: ... Jerykk
  32. Aug 11, 01:19  Define average Com
  33. Aug 11, 01:36  Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  34. Aug 11, 01:40 No subject danebramage
  35. Aug 11, 01:48  Re: No subject Jerykk
  36. Aug 11, 02:02   Re: No subject danebramage
  41. Aug 11, 04:33    Re: No subject Jerykk
  42. Aug 11, 10:07     Re: No subject Beamer
  43. Aug 11, 11:31      Re: No subject Wowbagger_TIP
  45. Aug 11, 11:49       Re: No subject the_culture
  48. Aug 11, 12:01        Re: No subject Wowbagger_TIP
  37. Aug 11, 02:09  Re: No subject Shadowcat
  38. Aug 11, 02:16  Re: No subject Wowbagger_TIP
  39. Aug 11, 02:41   Re: No subject danebramage
  40. Aug 11, 02:46    Re: No subject Wowbagger_TIP
  46. Aug 11, 11:55 ... theyarecomingforyou
  50. Aug 11, 12:16  Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  51. Aug 11, 12:23 ... theyarecomingforyou
  52. Aug 11, 12:30 ... theyarecomingforyou
  53. Aug 11, 13:23  Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  54. Aug 11, 13:32   Re: ... Beamer
  55. Aug 11, 13:34    Re: ... Beamer
  57. Aug 11, 13:48  Re: ... Bhruic
  58. Aug 11, 13:54   Re: ... the_culture
  60. Aug 11, 14:08    Re: ... Bhruic
  66. Aug 11, 21:56 ... theyarecomingforyou
  68. Aug 11, 22:42  Re: ... Wowbagger_TIP
  69. Aug 11, 23:32  Re: ... Jerykk
  70. Aug 12, 08:55 No subject dryden555


footer

.. .. ..

Blue's News logo