Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Carmack on PC Gaming

id Software's John Carmack and Marty Stratton Talk Quake Live, PC Gaming, and More on Shacknews offers a Q&A with id Software. Topics include the accessibility being built into Quake Live (or QUAKE LIVE, as the case may unfortunately be), Carmack's regrets that id "didn't have the manpower to do something that would be what we would consider our best foot forward" for the new iPhone (wtf?), Rage, community support, and more. Of particular interest are Mr. Carmack's reflections on a changing landscape for PC gaming:

Yeah, I think that the PC definitely can't.. we can't go on making PC games like we used to. The combination of the dominance of the consoles, as far as market forces there, and piracy.. the traditional AAA, media-heavy boxed game that sells for a bunch of money, and goes out on the PC for a single player experience--it's just not happening. Even if we look at something that had such a push like Crysis, it didn't really do all that well.

While at id Software we're still certainly doing those types of AAA titles on [the PC platform], we have to look at it from a cross-platform product perspective on there, rather than being PC-focused like we used to be. I mean, all the way up to our last major title, which was Doom 3, we were a PC company. We made PC games, and we gave some thought to how they might be deployed on consoles, but that wasn't what we were fundamentally doing. And that has changed with this generation.

But still, there are some things that the PC does fundamentally better than the console. I mean, the internet interaction, as far as displaying and navigating large amounts of information on a website--while you have web browsers on consoles, they suck, you know, they're just not good. It's not like what you've got on the PC.

And from a first person shooter perspective, the keyboard/mouse interface is still just a lot better than a console interface. It's a much more direct position vs. integrating over time.. it's just plain better, and that's one of the things we want to cater to.

So there are strengths that the PC has, and we think Quake Live is very much playing to them. While given infinite resources, yeah, it'd be great to go ahead and do another technology showcase on the PC, because you've got a couple times the power in a modern high-end system than you do in a current generation console.

But it's just not feasible for us as a company to continue taking that route. So we are branching out into some different areas and diversifying a little bit, where we've got our id Tech 5, cross-platform, high-end stuff that we are pushing, and we've also got Quake Live and our mobile products.

View
35. ... Jul 13, 2008, 18:01 theyarecomingforyou
 
Even Mass Effect was dumbed down - it basically stripped out half the features that made KOTOR so enjoyable. I enjoyed it but it didn't feel like a true PC game. Assassin's Creed came close but the combat mechanic was clearly designed for a controller and didn't work as well on PC. Bioshock doesn't count as a port because it was designed as multi-platform to start with.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Founder of the "I Hate Smiley Fitz" society

Remember: Riley has autism. He has trouble communicating, and in an overstimulating
environment, he can get frightened and run away, leaving his parents frantic. - Auburn
 
Avatar 22891
 
SteamID: theyarecomingforyou
Star Citizen: Blue's News
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Jul 13, 14:01 No subject manic half
  32. Jul 13, 17:54  Re: No subject Talisorn
  37. Jul 13, 18:16   Re: No subject Roachmojo
  2. Jul 13, 14:11 No subject MrTA
  3. Jul 13, 14:15  Re: No subject Tony!!!
  5. Jul 13, 14:26   Re: No subject Jerykk
  4. Jul 13, 14:24 No subject Tanto Edge
  6. Jul 13, 14:31 No subject Umbragen
  7. Jul 13, 14:44 No subject Wilson
  8. Jul 13, 14:57  What a tard badasscat
  14. Jul 13, 15:32  Re: No subject Paranoid Jack
  9. Jul 13, 14:58 PC Gaming ldonyo
  10. Jul 13, 15:18 No subject Hump
  13. Jul 13, 15:32  Re: No subject SirKnight
  11. Jul 13, 15:28 ... theyarecomingforyou
  20. Jul 13, 16:26  Re: ... Jerykk
  40. Jul 13, 18:29  Re: ... Umbragen
  42. Jul 13, 18:36   Re: ... Fuzzmatang
  50. Jul 13, 20:23    Re: ... sponge
  12. Jul 13, 15:29 ... theyarecomingforyou
  15. Jul 13, 15:34 No subject Tanto Edge
  16. Jul 13, 15:53  Re: No subject Enahs
  17. Jul 13, 16:06   Re: No subject badasscat
  19. Jul 13, 16:07   Re: No subject Paranoid Jack
  33. Jul 13, 17:57  Re: No subject sponge
  18. Jul 13, 16:06 No subject zirik
  21. Jul 13, 16:27 Many people lost respect for Carmack... JohnBirshire
  22. Jul 13, 16:38  Re: Many people lost respect for Carmack... Caveman
  23. Jul 13, 16:38 pc wins bigspender
  24. Jul 13, 16:42  Re: pc wins bigspender
  26. Jul 13, 17:15  Re: pc wins  dsmart 
  25. Jul 13, 16:56 ... theyarecomingforyou
  28. Jul 13, 17:21  Re: ... Fuzzmatang
  80. Jul 14, 03:23  Re: ... zirik
  27. Jul 13, 17:19 No subject PropheT
  29. Jul 13, 17:24 No subject Parallax Abstraction
  30. Jul 13, 17:32 No subject DangerDog
  31. Jul 13, 17:46 No subject Animals for Crackers
  34. Jul 13, 17:59  Re: No subject sponge
>> 35. Jul 13, 18:01 ... theyarecomingforyou
  36. Jul 13, 18:14  Re: ... Jerykk
  38. Jul 13, 18:16 baH, go hold Crytek's hand m0deth
  51. Jul 13, 20:25  Re: baH, go hold Crytek's hand sponge
  39. Jul 13, 18:27 No subject SamuraiSaint
  41. Jul 13, 18:36 No subject Xero
  61. Jul 13, 22:49  Re: No subject bigspender
  43. Jul 13, 18:38 No subject Exe
  44. Jul 13, 18:39 PC Gaming is Dead. Dreagon
  45. Jul 13, 18:45  Re: PC Gaming is Dead.  dsmart 
  46. Jul 13, 18:49 ... theyarecomingforyou
  48. Jul 13, 20:01  Re: ... Jerykk
  49. Jul 13, 20:06  Re: ... Asmodai
  47. Jul 13, 18:53 No subject Zzet
  52. Jul 13, 20:25 No subject Donkey_Punch
  53. Jul 13, 20:36 F.U.D. Kxmode
  54. Jul 13, 20:41 ... theyarecomingforyou
  56. Jul 13, 21:07  Re: ... Jerykk
  57. Jul 13, 21:50   Re: ... Tony!!!
  58. Jul 13, 21:52    Re: ... Tony!!!
  60. Jul 13, 21:56    Re: ... Jerykk
  55. Jul 13, 20:48 ... theyarecomingforyou
  59. Jul 13, 21:53  Re: ... swaaye
  82. Jul 14, 03:32  Re: ... zirik
  62. Jul 13, 22:50 ... theyarecomingforyou
  64. Jul 13, 23:01  Re: ... Jerykk
  65. Jul 13, 23:26   Re: ... elefunk
  71. Jul 14, 01:23    Re: ... sponge
  73. Jul 14, 02:00     Re: ... elefunk
  79. Jul 14, 03:21      Re: ... sponge
  87. Jul 14, 08:16     Re: ... Zuckuss
  104. Jul 16, 19:50      Re: ... Zuckuss
  75. Jul 14, 02:19    Re: ... JohnBirshire
  76. Jul 14, 02:58    Re: ... manic half
  77. Jul 14, 03:08     Re: ... elefunk
  81. Jul 14, 03:27      @ LMN8R Tanto Edge
  84. Jul 14, 03:35       Re: @ LMN8R zirik
  85. Jul 14, 03:38        change your subject line Tanto Edge
  86. Jul 14, 06:11       Re: change your subject line zirik
  67. Jul 13, 23:32   Id lost their Identity Zuckuss
  69. Jul 14, 01:19    Re: Id lost their Identity sponge
  70. Jul 14, 01:23     Re: Id lost their Identity Jerykk
  72. Jul 14, 01:24      Re: Id lost their Identity sponge
  102. Jul 14, 23:01   Re: ... Creston
  66. Jul 13, 23:28  Re: ... Asmodai
  63. Jul 13, 22:56 ... theyarecomingforyou
  68. Jul 14, 01:15 No subject KilrathiAce
  74. Jul 14, 02:11 No subject Ledge
  83. Jul 14, 03:33  Re: No subject Jerykk
  78. Jul 14, 03:19 ... theyarecomingforyou
  91. Jul 14, 10:37  Re: ... elefunk
  92. Jul 14, 11:18   Re: ... Paketep
  95. Jul 14, 15:38    Re: ... elefunk
  96. Jul 14, 15:47     Re: ... Animals for Crackers
  98. Jul 14, 15:53      Re: ... elefunk
  99. Jul 14, 16:03       Re: ... Animals for Crackers
  107. Jul 18, 05:17     Re: ... Paketep
  108. Jul 18, 05:21      Re: ... Paketep
  103. Jul 14, 23:10    Re: ... Creston
  88. Jul 14, 09:06 No subject dryden555
  89. Jul 14, 09:16 No subject dryden555
  90. Jul 14, 10:31 ... theyarecomingforyou
  93. Jul 14, 12:01  Re: ... Jerykk
  94. Jul 14, 14:11 ... theyarecomingforyou
  97. Jul 14, 15:52 ... theyarecomingforyou
  100. Jul 14, 16:47 ... theyarecomingforyou
  101. Jul 14, 22:44 Oh well Creston
  105. Jul 17, 18:45 No subject [VG]Reagle
  106. Jul 18, 02:29  Re: No subject bionicweirdo


footer

Blue's News logo