Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Redding, CA 06/22
Tampa, FL 06/26
Tampa, FL 10/04

Regularly scheduled events

Kane & Lynch Review Spin

Here's a little more controversy about Kane & Lynch reviews, already the subject of a firestorm over the GameSpot situation that surfaced last week (story). GameBump points out the Flash introduction on the Kane & Lynch: Dead Men features some finessed review quotes and scores that do not reflect the actual reception for IO Interactive's new action game. The intro lists the following blurbs, each preceded by five prominent stars: "'…it's the best emulation of being in the midst of a Michael Mann movie we've ever seen.' GameSpy," and 'A mercenary, a psychopath & a bundle of cash… what could go wrong? Game Informer'." The trouble is GameSpy gave the game three stars and Game Informer scored the game seven out of ten, and neither related quote is from the reviews, the GameSpy quote is from a E3 preview of the game, and it's not clear where the GameInformer quote/marketing blurb is from (presumably the print magazine). Finally, there's an article format Q&A with Jeff "Gertsmann" Gerstmann on Joystiq (thanks FiringSquad) where the ex-GameSpot editor cannot go into the reasons behind his parting with the website, but does defend his Kane & Lynch review, and says this recent experience does not leave him sharing the concern that "game writing is ethically bankrupt."

View
14. No subject Dec 3, 2007, 11:44 manic half
 
it actually seems that all of us here are not really that surprised.

 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Dec 3, 10:36 No subject Riker
  2. Dec 3, 10:59  Re: No subject sponge
  3. Dec 3, 11:04   Re: No subject Riker
  15. Dec 3, 11:47    Re: No subject Brian
  16. Dec 3, 12:00     Re: No subject xXBatmanXx
  18. Dec 3, 12:02     Re: No subject sir
  4. Dec 3, 11:04  Re: No subject Straylight
  8. Dec 3, 11:20   Re: No subject xXBatmanXx
  5. Dec 3, 11:08 No subject Hump
  9. Dec 3, 11:24  Re: No subject the_culture
  11. Dec 3, 11:27   Re: No subject nin
  13. Dec 3, 11:38   Re: No subject Ecthelion
  37. Dec 3, 15:30  Re: No subject dubfanatic
  46. Dec 3, 18:50  Re: No subject ledhead1969
  6. Dec 3, 11:15 No subject xXBatmanXx
  7. Dec 3, 11:19  Re: No subject nin
  10. Dec 3, 11:25   Re: No subject  cliffski 
  12. Dec 3, 11:35 uh... what? zirik
>> 14. Dec 3, 11:44 No subject manic half
  17. Dec 3, 12:01  The Escapist - Bad Example Golem
  24. Dec 3, 12:23   Re: The Escapist - Bad Example Tumbler
  25. Dec 3, 12:30    Re: The Escapist - Bad Example Jonny5
  26. Dec 3, 12:45     Re: The Escapist - Bad Example Nighthawk
  41. Dec 3, 16:33    Re: The Escapist - Bad Example Jerykk
  44. Dec 3, 17:16     Re: The Escapist - Bad Example the_culture
  45. Dec 3, 17:39      Re: The Escapist - Bad Example sponge
  49. Dec 3, 19:26       Re: The Escapist - Bad Example Tumbler
  52. Dec 3, 20:06        Re: The Escapist - Bad Example Jerykk
  53. Dec 3, 20:14         Re: The Escapist - Bad Example PHJF
  55. Dec 3, 21:15         Re: The Escapist - Bad Example Krovven
  19. Dec 3, 12:04 No subject Optimaximal
  20. Dec 3, 12:04 what is the big deal? Tumbler
  28. Dec 3, 13:14  Re: what is the big deal? Charlie_Six
  30. Dec 3, 13:40   Re: what is the big deal? Nighthawk
  31. Dec 3, 13:55    Re: what is the big deal? Charlie_Six
  47. Dec 3, 18:55     Re: what is the big deal? ledhead1969
  50. Dec 3, 19:27      Re: what is the big deal? Charlie_Six
  56. Dec 3, 21:26       Re: what is the big deal? dubfanatic
  58. Dec 3, 23:37        Re: what is the big deal? Golem
  59. Dec 7, 18:03         No subject Prez
  21. Dec 3, 12:11 No subject manic half
  23. Dec 3, 12:20  Re: No subject Golem
  22. Dec 3, 12:18 No subject KilrathiAce
  27. Dec 3, 13:09 No subject Big Frank
  29. Dec 3, 13:27 No subject xXBatmanXx
  32. Dec 3, 14:02 No subject Bone43
  33. Dec 3, 14:19  Re: No subject Krovven
  35. Dec 3, 14:51   Re: No subject Golem
  38. Dec 3, 15:46    Re: No subject Krovven
  39. Dec 3, 15:47    Re: No subject Tumbler
  40. Dec 3, 15:56     Re: No subject Golem
  42. Dec 3, 16:44      Re: No subject Krovven
  48. Dec 3, 19:17       Re: No subject Golem
  51. Dec 3, 19:44        Re: No subject Krovven
  43. Dec 3, 17:03   Re: No subject Bone43
  34. Dec 3, 14:42  Re: No subject Tumbler
  36. Dec 3, 15:22 No subject dryden555
  54. Dec 3, 20:53 LOL Tumbler
  57. Dec 3, 23:32  Re: LOL Jerykk


footer

.. ..

Blue's News logo