Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Carmack on Drivers

id Software's John Carmack made a Slashdot post to a thread called Futuremark Replies to Nvidia's Claims (thanks Jacek Fedoryñski) with some reflections on what does and does not constitute cheating relating to a discussion of the recent controversy (story), as well as a bit that offers some insight into video performance in DOOM 3:

The significant issue that clouds current ATI / Nvidia comparisons is fragment shader precision. Nvidia can work at 12 bit integer, 16 bit float, and 32 bit float. ATI works only at 24 bit float. There isn't actually a mode where they can be exactly compared. DX9 and ARB_fragment_program assume 32 bit float operation, and ATI just converts everything to 24 bit. For just about any given set of operations, the Nvidia card operating at 16 bit float will be faster than the ATI, while the Nvidia operating at 32 bit float will be slower. When DOOM runs the NV30 specific fragment shader, it is faster than the ATI, while if they both run the ARB2 shader, the ATI is faster.

View
57. Re: My experience with ATI Jun 3, 2003, 10:16 Tigger
 
Gee Anthony, I had a Radeon and NEVER had the kind of problems you had. No lockups, no difficulty installing the card or drivers, no problem with games working or not working - nothing. About the only problem I ever had with my Radeon (which led to its replacement) was the poor performance of the drivers. In true ATI style, however, the day I ordered my Geforce3, they came out with the Catalyst Drivers - but there wasn't that much of a gain, so I shelved it in favor of the Geforce3.

What happened to my old Radeon? I put it in a friends machine because their DVD Decoder card wouldn't work with their DVD-ROM. The Radeon worked (and still does) like a champ.


--
Tigger

'Got CS...gas?'
This comment was edited on Jun 3, 10:16.
 
Avatar 7252
 
--
Tigger
Vic Fontaine for President
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. May 27, 17:24 No subject ExcessDan
  3. May 27, 17:32  Re: No subject Wowbagger_TIP
  28. May 27, 22:58  Re: No subject pancreas
  29. May 27, 23:08   Re: No subject Virus
  2. May 27, 17:31 Hrm? Wolfen
  4. May 27, 18:16  Re: Hrm? nin
  6. May 27, 18:32   Re: Hrm? DrEvil
  5. May 27, 18:32 CarmackSpeak Da Stylin' Rastan
  7. May 27, 18:37 Tim Sweeney's comments Elvis
  8. May 27, 19:08 FP24 vs FP32 vacs
  11. May 27, 19:30  Re: FP24 vs FP32 Dave Baumann
  12. May 27, 19:42   Re: FP24 vs FP32 DrEvil
  41. May 28, 08:05    Re: FP24 vs FP32 Hump
  21. May 27, 21:14   Re: FP24 vs FP32 Mastaba
  22. May 27, 21:18    Re: FP24 vs FP32 Dave Baumann
  24. May 27, 21:41     Re: FP24 vs FP32 Mastaba
  26. May 27, 22:11      Re: FP24 vs FP32 Dave Baumann
  27. May 27, 22:40       Re: FP24 vs FP32 nin
  30. May 27, 23:45       Re: FP24 vs FP32 Mastaba
  9. May 27, 19:17 Lost Hump
  10. May 27, 19:24  Re: Lost ExcessDan
  14. May 27, 19:53  Re: Lost WarPig
  15. May 27, 19:58   Re: Lost Bunko
  17. May 27, 20:08    Re: Lost WarPig
  16. May 27, 19:59   Re: Lost Creston
  18. May 27, 20:09    Re: Lost Pete
  19. May 27, 20:22     Re: Lost The Truth
  25. May 27, 21:52      Re: Lost Bronco
  32. May 28, 00:12       Re: Lost WarPig
  33. May 28, 00:39        Re: Lost Ray Marden
  13. May 27, 19:50 No subject Hellbinder
  20. May 27, 20:43  Re: No subject NFNNMIDATA
  23. May 27, 21:26 No subject ExcessDan
  31. May 27, 23:57 My Card LordSteev
  38. May 28, 05:06  Re: My Card insulto
  40. May 28, 07:23   Re: My Card Raven737
  47. May 28, 10:09    Re: My Card Fingers M
  34. May 28, 01:42 No subject Hellbinder
  35. May 28, 03:24  Re: No subject hebrew_national
  51. May 28, 17:32   Re: No subject Wolfen
  36. May 28, 04:15  Re: No subject Anvil
  37. May 28, 04:55   Re: No subject seenitall
  39. May 28, 07:21    Re: No subject CultureShock
  42. May 28, 08:17 Monster card? wasrad
  43. May 28, 08:20  Re: Monster card? gildemere
  44. May 28, 08:47   Re: Monster card? wasrad
  48. May 28, 10:20    Re: Monster card? Von Helmet
  49. May 28, 11:30     Re: Monster card? Cynic9
  50. May 28, 15:13      Re: Monster card? Von Helmet
  52. May 28, 18:32       Re: Monster card? wasrad
  53. May 29, 13:42        Re: Monster card? Wolfen
  45. May 28, 09:27 No subject Cynic9
  46. May 28, 09:41  Re: No subject Bingo
  54. Jun 2, 20:24 My experience with ATI SirAnthony
  55. Jun 2, 23:43  Re: My experience with ATI Bronco
  56. Jun 3, 08:39  Re: My experience with ATI Von Helmet
>> 57. Jun 3, 10:16  Re: My experience with ATI Tigger
  58. Jun 3, 15:54  Re: My experience with ATI LordSteev


footer

Blue's News logo