Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

Edge Magazine - Assassin's Creed III devs: "Easy mode often ruins games".
"Itís like if I picked up a book and it said, 'Do you want the easy version or the complicated version?' [Game designers] can simplify the language, you know; we can make it two syllables."

Kotaku - Easy Modes Can Ruin Games? Um, No. Thanks nin.
It' just baffling to see that, in the year 2012, there are still people in the video game industry who approach things as though this was the 1980s, and the only games on the market were there to test you. If I don't have to pass a test just to turn a page in a book, or reach the second act of a movie, I shouldn't have to in a story-rich video game either.

View
18. Re: Op Ed Sep 4, 2012, 15:42 Scottish Martial Arts
 
I guess I just miss the days when beating a game was an actual accomplishment, rather than a preordained consequence of playing for 6-8 hours. Games are terrible at storytelling, probably because the people who write them generally aren't very literary -- Christ, look at David Gaider, or Chris Metzen -- so I have a hard time being sympathetic to the view that games need a Tell Me a Story Mode a la DXHR. What separates games from other media is gameplay, but gameplay is only engaging when there is a failure state. Would anyone watch a football game if your team was always guaranteed to win? Trying to remove failure states from gaming just spoils the whole experience, in my opinion. Furthermore, by making gameplay less engaging in favor of making it easy to see the end of a (terrible) story, developers are playing to the weakness of their medium rather than its strength. If adding an easy mode didn't affect the rest of the game design, I wouldn't have a problem with it -- people can skim chapters of novels that don't interest them too, although such a practice defeats the purpose of reading, but whatever -- but the reality is that designing a game around the inclusion of an easy mode generally alters the rest of the difficulty design as well. And that's why I can only support an easy mode with major caveats.

 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Sep 4, 09:50 Re: Op Ed Verno
  2. Sep 4, 09:55  Re: Op Ed briktal
  3. Sep 4, 10:06   Re: Op Ed finga
  6. Sep 4, 10:18   Re: Op Ed Verno
  4. Sep 4, 10:08 Re: Op Ed reisub
  7. Sep 4, 10:43  Re: Op Ed nin
  15. Sep 4, 14:26   Re: Op Ed Ruffiana
  5. Sep 4, 10:15 Re: Op Ed Silicon Avatar
  8. Sep 4, 11:11 Re: Op Ed Creston
  16. Sep 4, 14:39  Re: Op Ed Ratty
  17. Sep 4, 15:33   Re: Op Ed PHJF
>> 18. Sep 4, 15:42   Re: Op Ed Scottish Martial Arts
  19. Sep 4, 15:53    Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  20. Sep 4, 16:02     Re: Op Ed Kitkoan
  24. Sep 4, 18:04     Re: Op Ed Bhruic
  9. Sep 4, 11:51 Re: Op Ed Yakubs
  10. Sep 4, 12:22  Re: Op Ed PropheT
  11. Sep 4, 12:34   Re: Op Ed reisub
  12. Sep 4, 12:41    Re: Op Ed Verno
  13. Sep 4, 12:54     Re: Op Ed reisub
  14. Sep 4, 13:53      Re: Op Ed Flatline
  21. Sep 4, 16:23 Re: Op Ed Cutter
  22. Sep 4, 16:56  Re: Op Ed PHJF
  23. Sep 4, 17:47   Re: Op Ed Kitkoan
  28. Sep 4, 18:59    Re: Op Ed Beamer
  29. Sep 4, 19:12     Re: Op Ed PHJF
  30. Sep 4, 19:17      Re: Op Ed Beamer
  31. Sep 4, 20:03     Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  33. Sep 4, 23:30     Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  36. Sep 5, 07:46      Re: Op Ed Beamer
  37. Sep 6, 04:13       Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  27. Sep 4, 18:22  Re: Op Ed nin
  34. Sep 5, 01:12   Re: Op Ed Cutter
  25. Sep 4, 18:11 Re: Op Ed Acleacius
  26. Sep 4, 18:11 Re: Op Ed Mashiki Amiketo
  32. Sep 4, 22:10 Re: Op Ed Ant
  35. Sep 5, 02:48 Re: Op Ed jdreyer


footer

Blue's News logo