Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Greenbelt, MD 08/22

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

GameFront - Why I'm Not Okay with the Penny Arcade Kickstarter.
But Penny Arcade doesn't need money from Kickstarter, or to crowdsource new projects. It simply would prefer to remove ads from its site for one year, at the cost of a huge amount of money. But itís choosing to gather that money not through usual business channels, but through Kickstarter ó and in a way, itís taking advantage of the Kickstarter culture and drawing away users who would potentially give funds to more needy projects.

View
52. Re: Op Ed Jul 26, 2012, 13:38 Creston
 
Verno wrote on Jul 25, 2012, 13:00:
Ugh, I wish people would stop bitching at what goes on Kickstarter and what doesn't. The crowd in general decides what gets funded and what doesn't

I don't think that's fair at all. For example we all frequently complain about other people doing things in the videogame market despite our ability to just ignore them and exercise our personal preferences and purchase rights. I know you're a part of that as much as the rest of us too

This isn't a project, it's funding a well established, ongoing business for an indefinite period of time with no actual guidelines or standards. So yeah obviously I'm going to exercise my rights not to fund it but I'm also going to voice my displeasure that they're allowing it on there despite all of those things.

But that's kind of comparing apples to oranges. The whole idea behind Kickstarter is that a majority process decides whether something gets money or not. There's little to no comparison with the general game industry where a publisher decides that project A gets money, and it gets wasted. We've never had a say in that whatsoever, beyond the indirect manipulation of "If we buy 10 million copies of Game A, it's bound to get a sequel."

Do I think PA's could have just as easily done this another way? Yeah, I do. But I'm not going to go wag a moralizing finger at them and say that they're not allowed to try to do it through Kickstarter. I don't agree with it, so I don't give them any money. I'm not going to pre-emptively try to prohibit things like this from going ON Kickstarter.

Edit:
We know there are a lot of great projects that fall outside of our scope, but Kickstarter is not a place for soliciting donations to causes, charity projects, or general business expenses. Learn more about our project guidelines.

That's very interesting, actually. I had no idea that was in their ToS. I'm amazed they allowed PA on there, but I guess Kickstarter figures it's 10 million viewers worth of advertisement, so they're turning a blind eye.

Another thing which I'm less happy about than the PA thing is things like the Defense Grid 2 kickstarter. They put the KS at 250K, but the real thing I want, an actual DG2, is at one million. So if I donate, and they get 350K, and they take my money, but I don't get what I want, which is the sequel. It's kind of violating the entire idea behind it. But again, hey, if KS allows it, then they can go ahead and do it. I'm just not going to fund it until it reaches 999K (which seems highly unlikely, as they're just over 150K with 19 days left.)

Creston

This comment was edited on Jul 26, 2012, 13:44.
 
Avatar 15604
 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Jul 24, 21:08 Re: Op Ed Lokust
  2. Jul 24, 21:23  Re: Op Ed NKD
  3. Jul 24, 21:23  Re: Op Ed nin
  5. Jul 24, 21:30   Re: Op Ed jdreyer
  6. Jul 24, 21:35    Re: Op Ed Elf Shot The Food
  7. Jul 24, 21:36    Re: Op Ed Lorcin
  8. Jul 24, 21:37    Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  14. Jul 24, 22:01    Re: Op Ed Agent.X7
  4. Jul 24, 21:27  Re: Op Ed PropheT
  9. Jul 24, 21:38 Re: Op Ed Cutter
  10. Jul 24, 21:47  Re: Op Ed Prez
  16. Jul 24, 22:16   Re: Op Ed StingingVelvet
  17. Jul 24, 22:50    Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  18. Jul 24, 22:56     Re: Op Ed Beamer
  21. Jul 24, 23:16      Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  22. Jul 24, 23:36       Re: Op Ed Prez
  11. Jul 24, 21:47  Re: Op Ed NKD
  12. Jul 24, 21:52   Re: Op Ed PropheT
  13. Jul 24, 21:58    Re: Op Ed NKD
  19. Jul 24, 23:04     Re: Op Ed PropheT
  20. Jul 24, 23:15      Re: Op Ed NKD
  31. Jul 25, 03:31       Re: Op Ed Flatline
  24. Jul 25, 01:22      Re: Op Ed StingingVelvet
  25. Jul 25, 01:51       Re: Op Ed Dmitri_M
  27. Jul 25, 01:55        Re: Op Ed Prez
  28. Jul 25, 01:57         Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  29. Jul 25, 02:00          Re: Op Ed Prez
  30. Jul 25, 02:12         Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  26. Jul 25, 01:53       Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  32. Jul 25, 04:06        Re: Op Ed Dev
  15. Jul 24, 22:10 Re: Op Ed Silicon Avatar
  23. Jul 25, 00:00 Re: Op Ed Cyanotetyphas
  33. Jul 25, 04:48 Re: Op Ed xornand
  34. Jul 25, 09:07 Re: Op Ed Verno
  38. Jul 25, 10:36  Re: Op Ed RollinThundr
  39. Jul 25, 11:23   Re: Op Ed nin
  35. Jul 25, 10:18 Re: Op Ed Yakubs
  36. Jul 25, 10:21 Re: Op Ed Tumbler
  37. Jul 25, 10:23  Re: Op Ed Beamer
  40. Jul 25, 12:09 Re: Op Ed Creston
  41. Jul 25, 13:00 Re: Op Ed Verno
  42. Jul 25, 13:15  Re: Op Ed NKD
  44. Jul 25, 19:16   Re: Op Ed RollinThundr
>> 52. Jul 26, 13:38  Re: Op Ed Creston
  43. Jul 25, 13:48 Re: Op Ed Verno
  45. Jul 25, 19:54  Re: Op Ed Prez
  46. Jul 25, 20:50 Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  49. Jul 26, 09:50  Re: Op Ed RollinThundr
  50. Jul 26, 09:56   Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  51. Jul 26, 10:32    Re: Op Ed Verno
  54. Jul 26, 21:15     Re: Op Ed Sepharo
  47. Jul 25, 22:32 Re: Op Ed Dades
  48. Jul 26, 09:38 Re: Op Ed AlexSledge
  53. Jul 26, 14:41 Re: Op Ed Verno


footer

Blue's News logo