Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Morning Safety Dance

View
36. Re: Differences Jul 20, 2012, 23:05 shinchan0s
 
maleitch wrote on Jul 20, 2012, 19:33:
Sepharo wrote on Jul 20, 2012, 19:15:
Eliminating loopholes and exceptions is still seen as a tax increase. The "never raise my taxes ever for any reason" folks (and they're not just the ultra-wealthy) will fight any increase in the tax amount they pay regardless of where it comes from. In their mind the only direction taxes can go is down.

This gets so old. The evil McBain rich pay more in taxes than any other group. Quit pushing your childish morality on other people. You don't have a "right" to other people's income.

Funny how you never mention the "never touch my gubment benefits crowd" who actually call reductions in increases as cuts. When exactly are they going to be asked to pay their "fair share".

Oh and to this myth of wealth imbalance...Beamer you are going to try to tell me there was less disparity back in the days of Rockefeller and train barons.

Oh...in fact here is a story from today that blows your claim out of the water and it is even from CNBC so you can consider it legitimate:

http://www.cnbc.com/id/48257611




Lower class and middle class people suffer a bigger tax burden than you think when you take into account payroll, property and sales taxes. Labor, just like capital gains, is also taxed twice (first through SS and Medicare then income) so the double taxation argument can go out the window (although you could still argue that the SS tax is really a bargain investment for a future dividends - still, the tax is capped at, I think, $106,400 so it's a bigger burden for the middle class and it's doubtful future payouts will be as good as they are today). The whole tax argument is not even taking into account the rapidly growing costs of healthcare and education. Throw in the decades long wage stagnation and that's why you see lower and middle class Americans complain about taxes... even when their federal taxes are at historic lows.

It's true that the rich pay a lot in taxes. Actually, I think the top 20% pays somewhere like 70% of all federal taxes. It's shocking, I know. But it's not all that surprising when you consider how fast the top 1%'s income has grown. The fact of the matter is that the rich are paying a disproportionate share of taxes because they're receiving a disproportionate share of income.

I have no idea where you got this crazy notion that the ever widening wealth disparity in the USA is a myth. I also have no idea why you linked that CNBC article to try to disprove it. The only thing that article shows is that the top quintile's income is extremely variable in relation to all the other groups. Which we know, duh. The stock market tanked so all their capital gains went bye-bye. It's also historically always been that way. The funny thing is that it also shows the top 20% having over half of all income. Gee... I wonder why then they end up paying over half of all income taxes?

This post from the Economist's blog shows us that the tax burden isn't as uneven as you might think. The blog's data is backed up by the CBO report linked by your CNBC article. The top 20% have an effective total federal tax rate of 25% while the solidly middle class have historically paid 15%. That's not taking into account state and local taxes which are mostly regressive sales and property taxes.

Really, all I'm trying to say is that while, yes, the rich do pay a lot of income taxes, the effective tax rates of the rich are NOT AS OBSCENE as their share of total federal taxes paid might lead you to believe. I think that stat is skewed. The reality is that the top 20% pay two times the tax rate as the middle while having over 4-5 times the income. So, no, I don't think the rich are paying their fair share. They can afford to give a little extra. What are they gonna lose? Another yacht or Mercedes?

 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Jul 20, 11:45 Re: Morning Safety Dance Dev
  2. Jul 20, 12:15  Re: Morning Safety Dance Will W
  3. Jul 20, 12:23   Re: Morning Safety Dance Longswd
  7. Jul 20, 12:47    Re: Morning Safety Dance Will W
  23. Jul 20, 16:04     Re: Morning Safety Dance Dev
  24. Jul 20, 16:44      Re: Morning Safety Dance Beamer
  4. Jul 20, 12:26 put this in your pipe and smoke it space captain
  5. Jul 20, 12:35  Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Axis
  6. Jul 20, 12:42   Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it NegaDeath
  12. Jul 20, 13:56    Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it nin
  8. Jul 20, 13:30   Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Beamer
  11. Jul 20, 13:50    Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it RollinThundr
  13. Jul 20, 14:04     Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Beamer
  14. Jul 20, 14:43      Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it maleitch
  15. Jul 20, 14:55       Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Wowbagger_TIP
  16. Jul 20, 14:56       Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it NegaDeath
  18. Jul 20, 15:08        Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Beamer
  19. Jul 20, 15:18         Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Prez
  20. Jul 20, 15:20          Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it nin
  21. Jul 20, 15:21          Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Beamer
  22. Jul 20, 15:57         Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Spaced
  25. Jul 20, 16:48          Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Beamer
  26. Jul 20, 17:03          Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Wowbagger_TIP
  27. Jul 20, 17:38           Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Spaced
  28. Jul 20, 18:13            Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Wowbagger_TIP
  29. Jul 20, 19:15            Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Sepharo
  30. Jul 20, 19:33             Re: Differences maleitch
  31. Jul 20, 20:06              Re: Differences Sepharo
  35. Jul 20, 22:20               Re: Differences Prez
>> 36. Jul 20, 23:05              Re: Differences shinchan0s
  38. Jul 21, 19:50               Re: Differences RollinThundr
  39. Jul 21, 23:31                Re: Differences Wowbagger_TIP
  40. Jul 22, 00:40                 Re: Differences Prez
  41. Jul 22, 01:45                  Re: Differences RollinThundr
  42. Jul 22, 08:51                   Re: Differences shinchan0s
  43. Jul 22, 22:26                    Re: Differences RollinThundr
  44. Jul 23, 00:47                     Re: Differences Wowbagger_TIP
  45. Jul 23, 14:15                      Re: Differences RollinThundr
  46. Jul 23, 15:48                       Re: Differences Wowbagger_TIP
  47. Jul 23, 18:14                        Re: Differences RollinThundr
  48. Jul 23, 18:38                         Re: Differences Sepharo
  49. Jul 23, 19:30                         Re: Differences Wowbagger_TIP
  51. Jul 25, 10:48                          Re: Differences RollinThundr
  52. Jul 25, 11:21                           Re: Differences Wowbagger_TIP
  53. Jul 25, 18:26                            Re: Differences RollinThundr
  54. Jul 26, 17:43                             Re: Differences Wowbagger_TIP
  17. Jul 20, 15:06       Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Beamer
  9. Jul 20, 13:35   Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it Wowbagger_TIP
  10. Jul 20, 13:40    Re: put this in your pipe and smoke it mag
  32. Jul 20, 20:14 Re: Morning Safety Dance space captain
  33. Jul 20, 20:33 Re: Morning Safety Dance Cutter
  34. Jul 20, 20:46  Re: Morning Safety Dance nin
  37. Jul 21, 02:57 Re: Morning Safety Dance dj LiTh
  50. Jul 25, 06:42 Re: Morning Safety Dance AnointedSword


footer

.. .. ..

Blue's News logo