Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Greenbelt, MD 08/22

Regularly scheduled events

Out of the Blue

MrsBlue is home from work today, which should have provided a perfect opportunity to continue the discussion of whether to pop an air conditioner into one of the windows in the living room. That is, of course, if it wasn't for the rainstorm that has taken the local temperature down to 66F at the moment, which I'm pretty sure is not going to help my argument. As usual, the key to life is timing.

R.I.P.: Al Franken's 'SNL' partner, Tom Davis, dies in NY.
R.I.P.: Sylvia Woods, who started Harlem restaurant, dies.

Well-Timed Links: Thanks Ant and Acleacius.
Play: Overhaul.
Wasted Colony.
Stories: 14 Killed At "Knight Rises" Screening.
Congressional insider trading ban might not apply to families.
US food aid: the special interests blocking reform.
Science: Compounds coax HIV out of hiding so it can be eliminated.
Altruism, Brain Region Called Temporoparietal Junction Linked In University Of Zurich Study.
Images: State Farm Split Camaro Project. Thanks The Flying Penguin.
Media: The Matrix: Reloaded & Rewritten.
How to Explode a Watermelon Using Rubber Bands. In Super Slow Motion. Thanks nin.
NYC Geyser Spits Cigarette Butts.
Auction: Back to the Future Delorean up for auction.

View
34. Re: Out of the Blue Jul 21, 2012, 11:31 kanniballl
 
Mr. Tact wrote on Jul 21, 2012, 08:25:
I'm not saying it will or should go this way legally, but on some level the shooter is clearly insane. No same person purposely goes to a movie and kills a dozen people and wounds dozens more. Given that, I don't see how it can be used properly as an example for or against anything.

One can make that argument about ANY killer then... there's obviously something "wrong" with a person that would kill someone for little-to-no reason. Or pedophiles for that matter. Or really, just about any violent crime that wasn't to "get away" with something else (robbery, etc). Having a mental issue or abnormal behavior doesn't immediately give you the legal insanity defense.


I believe the measuring stick is: if the person knew what was going on, and understood the immediate consequences of his actions (dead people, injured people, etc), and was based in reality (not hallucinating / thinking he was shooting Zombies / etc).

  • If he honestly thought he was saving the world from Pod People an was doing the world a favor... then he'd skate on insanity.
  • If he thought it was a message from god, then he could probably skate.
  • If he was mentally handicapped and was convinced "this would make him cool" then he'd skate, but the people that forced his hand wouldn't.


  • If it just wanted to kill them to make sure "The Avengers" stayed the number 1 summer flick... then as demented as that is, I don't think it's grounds for insanity.

    If he just wanted to make a name for himself as a large-count spree killer, then it wouldn't be grounds.

    I'm not saying he WAS legally sane... just that doing something the public would think is crazy doesn't necessarily mean the suspect is legally insane.


    -

    This comment was edited on Jul 21, 2012, 11:48.
     
    "Space. It seems to go on and on forever. But then you get to the end and a gorilla starts throwing barrels at you."
    -Fry, Futurama
    Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
     
        Date Subject Author
      1. Jul 20, 10:42 Re: Out of the Blue nin
      31. Jul 21, 04:52  Re: Out of the Blue The Half Elf
      32. Jul 21, 07:27   Re: Out of the Blue Bet
      2. Jul 20, 10:43 14 Killed At "Knight Rises" Screening. kanniballl
      3. Jul 20, 10:48 14 Killed At "Knight Rises" Screening Hyatus
      4. Jul 20, 10:50  Re: 14 Killed At kanniballl
      6. Jul 20, 13:08  Re: 14 Killed At xXBatmanXx
      7. Jul 20, 13:12   Re: 14 Killed At kanniballl
      10. Jul 20, 14:18   Re: 14 Killed At mch
      11. Jul 20, 14:19    Re: 14 Killed At kanniballl
      5. Jul 20, 11:55 Re: Out of the Blue Mashiki Amiketo
      8. Jul 20, 13:34 Re: Out of the Blue Wallshadows
      9. Jul 20, 14:16 Re: Out of the Blue Bet
      12. Jul 20, 15:30 Re: Out of the Blue Jivaro
      13. Jul 20, 15:42  Re: Out of the Blue kanniballl
      14. Jul 20, 15:56   Re: Out of the Blue Agent.X7
      15. Jul 20, 16:03    Re: Out of the Blue Raven
      16. Jul 20, 16:09     Re: Out of the Blue xmb1121
      17. Jul 20, 17:08      Re: Out of the Blue PHJF
      18. Jul 20, 19:03 Re: Out of the Blue Sepharo
      20. Jul 20, 20:19  Re: Out of the Blue PHJF
      22. Jul 20, 21:51  Re: Out of the Blue Jivaro
      23. Jul 20, 22:05   Re: Out of the Blue Sepharo
      19. Jul 20, 19:53 It came from DMC 12 space captain
      21. Jul 20, 20:50 Re: Out of the Blue Cutter
      24. Jul 20, 23:00  Re: Out of the Blue Matshock
      25. Jul 21, 00:22   Re: Out of the Blue Cutter
      26. Jul 21, 00:52    Re: Out of the Blue Matshock
      27. Jul 21, 01:04     Re: Out of the Blue PHJF
      28. Jul 21, 01:24      Re: Out of the Blue Matshock
      36. Jul 22, 10:34       Re: Out of the Blue Fang
      37. Jul 22, 13:58        Re: Out of the Blue Matshock
      38. Jul 22, 15:45         Re: Out of the Blue Prez
      39. Jul 22, 17:24          Re: Out of the Blue Matshock
      40. Jul 22, 20:40           Re: Out of the Blue Prez
      29. Jul 21, 01:46    Re: Out of the Blue Prez
      30. Jul 21, 04:27     Re: Out of the Blue Ventura
      33. Jul 21, 08:25 Re: Out of the Blue Mr. Tact
    >> 34. Jul 21, 11:31  Re: Out of the Blue kanniballl
      35. Jul 21, 13:36  Re: Out of the Blue Mr. Tact


    footer

    Blue's News logo