Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

IGN - Is Metacritic Ruining The Games Industry?
It also leads to some very dodgy behaviour from the publisher side of things. Iíve been told stories of PR executives working on particular games being directed to specifically target these smaller sites in the hope of raising that average score and covering up a less enthusiastic reception from the big outlets. For most people working in games marketing, Metacritic will come up during their annual review process, and a less-than-ideal average score for a game will sometimes result in a severe bollocking.

View
18. Re: Op Ed Jul 18, 2012, 13:30 eunichron
 
As much as I want to jump on Creston's IGN hatewagon, the article has a point, though, not by the means they were talking about.

Metacritic is made up of two styles of reviews; professional (and I use that term extremely lightly) reviewers, and user reviews. The professional reviews can be swayed as we have seen in the past through extortion by marketing and outright corruption, or the reviewers are just simply bad reviewers, not much better than the standard User review on the website. User reviews are usually day-0 reviews that follow the flavor of the week, and are purely subjective. There are games where there is a loosely organized effort to bomb the Metacritic score simply because of a single feature (Diablo 3) or an irrational hatred of the title (SW:TOR), or because of shoddy business practice (Mass Effect 3), and in all cases it is regardless of the actual quality of the game itself.

In both cases the reviews can't be trusted. They are not an accurate representation of the game itself, and instead become a reflection of the floundering relationship between publishers and reviewers, or the irrational vitriol of gamers on a crusade. It is in that regard that Metacritic is ruining the games industry, but only as long users put any value on it. If users were smart enough to realize that professional reviewers are paid shills, or that 4chan's /v/ regularly bombs scores of games purely because of personal vendetta, then Metacritic has no effect at all.

Bottom line is the only reviewer you can trust is yourself.
 
Avatar 13977
 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Jul 18, 10:15 Re: Op Ed ASeven
  2. Jul 18, 10:19  Re: Op Ed InBlack
  3. Jul 18, 10:26  Re: Op Ed nin
  4. Jul 18, 10:45 Re: Op Ed Acleacius
  5. Jul 18, 10:49  Re: Op Ed nin
  7. Jul 18, 11:27   Re: Op Ed MisterBenn
  8. Jul 18, 11:39    Re: Op Ed Prez
  16. Jul 18, 13:19    Re: Op Ed theglaze
  6. Jul 18, 11:27 Re: Op Ed Silicon Avatar
  21. Jul 18, 14:59  Re: Op Ed StingingVelvet
  9. Jul 18, 12:18 Re: Op Ed theyarecomingforyou
  13. Jul 18, 12:39  Re: Op Ed Prez
  23. Jul 18, 15:05   Re: Op Ed theyarecomingforyou
  24. Jul 18, 15:36    Re: Op Ed Darks
  29. Jul 18, 16:15  Re: Op Ed Axis
  32. Jul 18, 20:03   Re: Op Ed SimplyMonk
  33. Jul 18, 20:10    Re: Op Ed Dmitri_M
  35. Jul 18, 20:31     Re: Op Ed Mashiki Amiketo
  36. Jul 18, 22:55      Re: Op Ed Dmitri_M
  37. Jul 19, 04:18       Re: Op Ed InBlack
  38. Jul 19, 07:44        Re: Op Ed Beamer
  39. Jul 19, 09:29         Re: Op Ed InBlack
  40. Jul 19, 09:56          Re: Op Ed Beamer
  41. Jul 19, 10:00           Re: Op Ed InBlack
  10. Jul 18, 12:18 Re: Op Ed Creston
  12. Jul 18, 12:33  Re: Op Ed shinchan0s
  14. Jul 18, 12:42  Re: Op Ed PropheT
  15. Jul 18, 12:51   Re: Op Ed Fantaz
  26. Jul 18, 15:42  Re: Op Ed Darks
  31. Jul 18, 19:55   Re: Op Ed PropheT
  11. Jul 18, 12:24 Re: Op Ed Verno
  17. Jul 18, 13:24 Re: Op Ed Tumbler
>> 18. Jul 18, 13:30 Re: Op Ed eunichron
  19. Jul 18, 13:48  Re: Op Ed Prez
  20. Jul 18, 13:55   Re: Op Ed eunichron
  22. Jul 18, 15:00    Re: Op Ed Prez
  25. Jul 18, 15:41 Re: Op Ed avianflu
  27. Jul 18, 15:42 Re: Op Ed briktal
  28. Jul 18, 16:11  Re: Op Ed eunichron
  30. Jul 18, 18:11 Re: Op Ed NiteX
  34. Jul 18, 20:11 Re: Op Ed SimplyMonk


footer

Blue's News logo