Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Team 6 versus Eurogamer

A post to the Steam Users' Forums by Team 6's Ronnie Nelis calls out Eurogamer for its scathing review of Flatout 3: Chaos & Destruction, which gave the racing sequel a miniscule 1/10 ranking. Nelis calls the reviewer a "liar," saying the review was copied (thanks Joao). A subsequent post expands:

If you don't believe the text, check the screens: They don't show any deformation for example, someting that is present for quite some weeks now. There's only one reason how this is all possible: He is playing a non-official, old version of the game. It's not what people see when they purchase the game, thus not representive.

Also worth noticing: our publisher has only sent out review copies to the press as from today.. (so how could he have 'received' it earlier?)

I don't mind people complaining, giving feedback, or just disliking the game in general. I have plenty of positive and happy fanmail to cheer me up again after reading this article, but what bothers me is that he is not telling the truth. Shouldn't a reporter be fair and tell the truth?

If you are interested in fair reviews, i currenly recommend the one on gamespot. http://www.gamespot.com/flatout-3-ch...%3Bread-review

To make this comparision fair: This one is not positive neither, but the text is open-minded, fair and therefore better. The gamespot reporter also used an old version and not the official publisher-review copy which has been sent out only today BUT he did actually played and obviously enjoyed the game. Worth noticing: The two things he marks as "bad" are completely fixed nowadays. (too bad we can't get a re-review hehe)

View
50. Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Jan 7, 2012, 11:36 theyarecomingforyou
 
JaguarUSF wrote on Jan 7, 2012, 07:48:
Correct. But when you can't afford to buy your own copies of games (there's no way in hell I would buy FlatOut 3 just for a review), you are at the mercy of the publisher.
Yeah, I understand that for smaller sites like yours. The very idea that publishers are sending out a different copy to the one released is disgusting. It's different for sites like Eurogamer, that can easily cover the cost of buying the game at retail from advertising revenue. For them the longer they take to review the game the less interest there is in it, so they don't have to pander to publishers.

I'm perfectly happy for review sites to take longer to review a game than have them manipulated and restricted by publishers. If I'm really interested in a game I'll usually pre-order it - if I have any concerns I'll hold off for the reviews and I'm really not interested in the typical fluff pieces that sites like Gamespy and IGN are famous for.
 
Avatar 22891
 
SteamID: theyarecomingforyou
Star Citizen: Blue's News
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Jan 6, 10:55 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Creston
  2. Jan 6, 10:58  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Bludd
  3. Jan 6, 10:59   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer nin
  29. Jan 6, 16:54    Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer xXBatmanXx
  32. Jan 6, 19:39     Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Prez
  33. Jan 6, 20:05      Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Elf Shot The Food
  9. Jan 6, 12:04  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Prez
  10. Jan 6, 12:08   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer PHJF
  24. Jan 6, 15:11    Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Creston
  25. Jan 6, 15:12     Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer nin
  26. Jan 6, 15:38      Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Creston
  27. Jan 6, 16:07      Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Quboid
  11. Jan 6, 12:12   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer briktal
  13. Jan 6, 12:14   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer ASeven
  4. Jan 6, 11:01 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Kajetan
  5. Jan 6, 11:08  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Overon
  6. Jan 6, 11:21   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Kajetan
  12. Jan 6, 12:12    Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer ASeven
  14. Jan 6, 12:17     Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Prez
  15. Jan 6, 12:29      Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer ASeven
  16. Jan 6, 12:30      Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Jerykk
  17. Jan 6, 12:34       Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer ASeven
  18. Jan 6, 12:42        Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Panickd
  19. Jan 6, 12:50         Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Prez
  20. Jan 6, 12:59          Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Verno
  21. Jan 6, 13:04           Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Beamer
  7. Jan 6, 12:01 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer meezookeewee
  8. Jan 6, 12:04  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Elf Shot The Food
  22. Jan 6, 13:12 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Jerusahat
  23. Jan 6, 14:32  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer killer_roach
  28. Jan 6, 16:37 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer theyarecomingforyou
  30. Jan 6, 17:31  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Beamer
  31. Jan 6, 19:15  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer eRe4s3r
  34. Jan 6, 20:21 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer JaguarUSF
  35. Jan 6, 20:27  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Sepharo
  42. Jan 6, 23:13  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer theyarecomingforyou
  43. Jan 6, 23:35   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Jerykk
  48. Jan 7, 07:48   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer JaguarUSF
>> 50. Jan 7, 11:36    Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer theyarecomingforyou
  44. Jan 6, 23:41  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer ASeven
  45. Jan 7, 02:09  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer nin
  36. Jan 6, 20:50 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer jdreyer
  37. Jan 6, 20:57  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer killer_roach
  38. Jan 6, 21:00 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Bhruic
  39. Jan 6, 21:55  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Prez
  40. Jan 6, 22:31   Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer killer_roach
  41. Jan 6, 22:46    Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Prez
  46. Jan 7, 03:10 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer EricFate
  47. Jan 7, 06:03  Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer Fantaz
  49. Jan 7, 08:41 Re: Team 6 versus Eurogamer ASeven


footer

Blue's News logo