Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Skyrim Soars

The Steam Game and Player Statistics Page shows The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim as the most played game by current player count as of this writing, with more players than all the other games on the list combined. This also show today's peak number of concurrent users for Bethesda's new RPG sequel was 231,593. Thanks Acleacius via FPSWin. And for your tweaking pleasure: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim How To Enable Ambient Occlusion. And for your larcenous side: How to steal in Skyrim.

View
36. Re: Skyrim Soars Nov 12, 2011, 10:53 wtf_man
 
Cutter wrote on Nov 12, 2011, 00:12:
wtf_man wrote on Nov 11, 2011, 22:49:
Done for the day. So far, it's looking like the best game in the series (other than the UI and food needing to be more needed / meaningful). I progressed the main quest to the point of killing my first dragon / activating my first shout... then concentrated on side quests for the Companions (Warriors Guild).

I'm having an effin' blast!!!

It has a nice flavour and look but it's very RPG-lite. Hardly the best game in the series as it's been dumbed down a vast amount for broad audience appeal. I can live with it but it's rather dissapointing. ... ... (snip)

I think "everyone" on post 28 gave out some good answers... but I'll re-iterate.

The first thing that counts, to me, is "Am I immersed in this world"? Compared to Oblivion and Morrowind... absolutely. They finally got quest flow and main story "presented correctly", so you don't get bored and think to yourself "what do I do next?" At the same time it's not "hand holding" and you can do whatever you want. It's the balance of these things that Elder Scrolls games have needed for ages.

As for nitpicking the rest:

3 Stats, No Classes, and no Major Minor Skills:
Personally... I prefer skill based RPGs to classes. And that's what Bethesda has evolved to. Meridian 59 and Asheron's Call are good MMO examples of skill based RPGs. You "create" you class by spending some sort of points, or always using the type of skill that you want to develop. While the 3 Stats + Perk System may seem dumbed down compared to traditional 6-8 stats and points spent exactly on a large amount of skills to choose from...I think the perk skill tree replaces that nicely, and most of the skills are still there.

No Birth signs:
Guardian Stones are indeed the replacement. They actually make more sense, because you can activate what you want as you go, instead of being stuck with 1 bonus at the beginning of the game.

Equipment Deterioration:
I admit, I wish that was still in... but lightly implemented. A good sword should last several real-life days of hacking at mobs before you have to do any maintenance.

Throwing Weapons:
I don't really care... and didn't ever use them in the previous games. There are plenty of "ranged" choices... including shouts, now.

No spell making / Potion Naming:
Well, I guess that's more restrictive for casters, but honestly crafting potions and enchanting isn't enough? Ok... I'm sure someone will come up with a mod that will let you make spells and name potions again. It's not a huge game breaker for me... again... immersion in the world comes first to me, and Skyrim does that well.

The rest of the list:
Mr. "everyone" answered those pretty well.

The argument of whether it's a "true CRPG" / or "RPG Lite" is subjective. For me, if I can't get immersed in the world, it's not worth any label other than "it sucks". I've been playing CRPGs since the early 80's and table-top RPGs since the late 70's (Yes, I'm an old fart that isn't part of the ADHD Entitlement Generation). I find the amount of character "micro-managment" in Skyrim to be sufficient. I actually do have a strategy for the perk tree, so obviously it's not all that "dumbed down".

Are there some little "micro-managing" bits that I miss? Sure... but nothing overly game breaking to be "Disappointed" in the game as a whole.

I stand by my original opinion... I think this game is looking to be the best in the series... both presentation-wise and immersion-wise.

If some little micro-managment thing is not available to you anymore, and it ruins the whole game for you... maybe you are TOO "Hard Core".

This comment was edited on Nov 12, 2011, 10:58.
 
Avatar 19499
 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Nov 11, 22:19 Re: Skyrim Soars Tanto Edge
  2. Nov 11, 22:23  Re: Skyrim Soars Cutter
  3. Nov 11, 22:32  Re: Skyrim Soars Xirix
  5. Nov 11, 22:48   Re: Skyrim Soars StingingVelvet
  4. Nov 11, 22:47  Re: Skyrim Soars StingingVelvet
  6. Nov 11, 22:49 Re: Skyrim Soars wtf_man
  7. Nov 11, 23:11  Re: Skyrim Soars Draugr
  8. Nov 11, 23:21   Re: Skyrim Soars Scud
  12. Nov 12, 00:12  Re: Skyrim Soars Cutter
  17. Nov 12, 01:05   Re: Skyrim Soars LittleMe
  21. Nov 12, 01:58   Re: Skyrim Soars StingingVelvet
  22. Nov 12, 03:07    Re: Skyrim Soars Fion
  23. Nov 12, 03:21     Re: Skyrim Soars Scottish Martial Arts
  24. Nov 12, 03:47      Re: Skyrim Soars Agent.X7
  25. Nov 12, 04:09       Re: Skyrim Soars Scottish Martial Arts
  26. Nov 12, 04:59        Re: Skyrim Soars Draugr
  27. Nov 12, 05:52         Re: Skyrim Soars Jerykk
  35. Nov 12, 10:26        Re: Skyrim Soars PsychoMoggieBagpuss
  28. Nov 12, 06:32   Re: Skyrim Soars everyone
  41. Nov 12, 11:17    Re: Skyrim Soars Creston
  34. Nov 12, 09:53   Re: Skyrim Soars finga
>> 36. Nov 12, 10:53   Re: Skyrim Soars wtf_man
  9. Nov 11, 23:47 Re: Skyrim Soars Esoteric
  10. Nov 12, 00:05  Re: Skyrim Soars Beelzebud
  13. Nov 12, 00:13   Re: Skyrim Soars nin
  11. Nov 12, 00:07 Re: Skyrim Soars heroin
  40. Nov 12, 11:11  Re: Skyrim Soars Creston
  44. Nov 12, 11:28   Re: Skyrim Soars Linksil
  57. Nov 12, 13:46    Re: Skyrim Soars Creston
  61. Nov 12, 14:06     Re: Skyrim Soars StingingVelvet
  62. Nov 12, 15:45      removed CJ_Parker
  67. Nov 12, 23:01      Re: Skyrim Soars Linksil
  71. Nov 13, 10:57       Re: Skyrim Soars StingingVelvet
  72. Nov 13, 11:32        Re: Skyrim Soars Linksil
  73. Nov 13, 12:01         Re: Skyrim Soars StingingVelvet
  14. Nov 12, 00:23 Re: Skyrim Soars Kastagir
  16. Nov 12, 01:04  Re: Skyrim Soars Hump
  18. Nov 12, 01:10   Re: Skyrim Soars LittleMe
  19. Nov 12, 01:38   Re: Skyrim Soars DrEvil
  20. Nov 12, 01:54    Re: Skyrim Soars Kastagir
  15. Nov 12, 00:35 Re: Skyrim Soars DrEvil
  29. Nov 12, 08:00 Re: Skyrim Soars MrBone
  30. Nov 12, 08:12 Re: Skyrim Soars everyone
  31. Nov 12, 08:41  Re: Skyrim Soars LgFriess
  32. Nov 12, 09:00   Re: Skyrim Soars Slashman
  33. Nov 12, 09:40    Re: Skyrim Soars Angrius Maximis
  37. Nov 12, 11:02 Re: Skyrim Soars Mashiki Amiketo
  38. Nov 12, 11:08 Re: Skyrim Soars Eldaron Imotholin
  42. Nov 12, 11:20  Re: Skyrim Soars wtf_man
  39. Nov 12, 11:09 Re: Skyrim Soars Creston
  47. Nov 12, 12:12  Re: Skyrim Soars briktal
  56. Nov 12, 13:43   Re: Skyrim Soars Creston
  43. Nov 12, 11:27 Re: Skyrim Soars Creston
  59. Nov 12, 13:51  Re: Skyrim Soars DrEvil
  60. Nov 12, 13:55   Re: Skyrim Soars Creston
  63. Nov 12, 16:02    Re: Skyrim Soars Lord Tea
  64. Nov 12, 18:17     Re: Skyrim Soars StingingVelvet
  65. Nov 12, 18:56      Re: Skyrim Soars Mashiki Amiketo
  66. Nov 12, 22:14       Re: Skyrim Soars xXBatmanXx
  68. Nov 12, 23:55      Re: Skyrim Soars Lord Tea
  69. Nov 13, 03:30       Re: Skyrim Soars NicklePop
  70. Nov 13, 07:48       Re: Skyrim Soars Jerykk
  45. Nov 12, 11:57 Re: Skyrim Soars wtf_man
  46. Nov 12, 12:05  Re: Skyrim Soars J
  48. Nov 12, 12:16  Re: Skyrim Soars Angrius Maximis
  49. Nov 12, 12:36   Re: Skyrim Soars wtf_man
  50. Nov 12, 12:42    Re: Skyrim Soars Eldaron Imotholin
  51. Nov 12, 12:53    Re: Skyrim Soars Quboid
  52. Nov 12, 13:15   Re: Skyrim Soars Agent.X7
  54. Nov 12, 13:25   Re: Skyrim Soars Quboid
  55. Nov 12, 13:32    Re: Skyrim Soars Tim Collins
  58. Nov 12, 13:49   Re: Skyrim Soars dangerman77
  53. Nov 12, 13:20  Re: Skyrim Soars Yaogun
  74. Nov 13, 16:56 Re: Skyrim Soars EricFate
  75. Nov 14, 02:32 Re: Skyrim Soars Eldaron Imotholin
  76. Nov 14, 03:14  Re: Skyrim Soars Sepharo
  78. Nov 15, 03:03   Re: Skyrim Soars Eldaron Imotholin
  77. Nov 14, 07:27  Re: Skyrim Soars Mangrove


footer

.. .. ..

Blue's News logo