Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview

As promised, here's my Diablo III Beta Preview, based on some hands-on time with the closed beta of Blizzard's upcoming action/RPG sequel. I had fun playing the beta and writing the piece, and again marvel at how people can write comprehensive reviews of full games when it took me so long to get this out based on a beta that can be completed in three hours. Thanks to my friends MrKawfy and Overthecledge for playing with me and to MrsBlue for her invaluable proofreading. Here's a sample:

There is less fear of making mistakes that will go on your permanent record and follow you around for the rest of your life, as my elementary school principal used to say. There are no choices for characteristics—this is all automatic. As you level up, you earn active and passive skills but you can change them any time you want. Skills are no longer tree-based, so you don't have to pick a crappy one to get the better one that follows. The death penalty is now almost non-existent: You respawn at the last checkpoint with a ten-percent loss of durability to your equipment, which seems fairly trivial and removes the fear of venturing too far past your current abilities. I find this regrettable: One of the most memorable experiences of my gaming life was a late night when my party got killed in the depths of a Diablo dungeon: We literally spent hours working out how to retrieve our items from where they dropped. I prefer it much more where you dread dying, but I don't know how realistic it is to expect this to be changed.

View
51. Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Oct 5, 2011, 01:02 Bhruic
 
Yeah, to me that's called "Dumbing stuff down."
Because if they cared so much about everyone picking the same attribute, they could have also made the other attributes more interesting to pick, and keep the old system.

In general, I'm all for more choice in games, but only if the choices are meaningful. Diablo II had a system that didn't really have meaningful choices, so they removed it. Yes, another option would have been to try and make the other attributes more useful to pick, but I don't see how they'd accomplish that easily. I suspect they thought they'd done that for II. Barring that, removing what was effectively pointless choices seems like a smart call - as long as they continue to have other meaningful choices in the game.

Calling it "dumbing down" just seems silly, as there was nothing "smart" about it before.

I like how when this happened in Mass Effect 2, everyone and their mom called it "Dumbing down", but when it happens in Diablo it "just makes sense!"

Well, I never commented about any "dumbing down" in Mass Effect 2, so that doesn't seem to apply to me. But even if I had, I'm not sure of the relevance. Just because something seemed like a bad call on an RPG doesn't mean it's going to be a bad call on an action game. And that's even assuming that the cases were identical, which they aren't.

If the variety and choices of character building aren't there for DIII, then I'll be among the first to knock Blizzard for it, but just because they've switched the way they go about their variety doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
 
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Oct 4, 15:20 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview mark gil
  2. Oct 4, 15:27  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview nin
  4. Oct 4, 15:30   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview SpectralMeat
  3. Oct 4, 15:30  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Beamer
  10. Oct 4, 15:49  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview mch
  12. Oct 4, 15:59   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Slashman
  5. Oct 4, 15:31 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Creston
  6. Oct 4, 15:34  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Tumbler
  8. Oct 4, 15:37   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview SpectralMeat
  7. Oct 4, 15:36 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Verno
  9. Oct 4, 15:47 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview LaxerFL
  11. Oct 4, 15:50  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview nin
  24. Oct 4, 18:08   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview shul
  15. Oct 4, 16:40  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Keilun
  16. Oct 4, 16:42  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Alamar
  18. Oct 4, 17:08   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Keilun
  22. Oct 4, 18:01  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Creston
  26. Oct 4, 18:18  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Bhruic
  32. Oct 4, 19:22  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Dev
  41. Oct 4, 20:36  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview jdreyer
  13. Oct 4, 16:00 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Cutter
  14. Oct 4, 16:16 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Paketep
  17. Oct 4, 16:50 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Bhruic
  19. Oct 4, 17:21  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview  Blue 
  20. Oct 4, 17:51   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Theo
  21. Oct 4, 17:54    Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview  Blue 
  25. Oct 4, 18:16     Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview RogNog
  35. Oct 4, 19:34      Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Draugr
  42. Oct 4, 20:50      Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview jdreyer
  29. Oct 4, 19:06     Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Hump
  55. Oct 5, 03:03     Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Theo
  56. Oct 5, 05:13      Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview InBlack
  23. Oct 4, 18:06 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview shul
  27. Oct 4, 18:36 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview LaxerFL
  28. Oct 4, 19:06  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Cutter
  30. Oct 4, 19:13  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Luke
  33. Oct 4, 19:24   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Fibrocyte
  31. Oct 4, 19:20  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Bhruic
  34. Oct 4, 19:32 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview eunichron
  37. Oct 4, 19:52  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Bhruic
  54. Oct 5, 02:01   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview eunichron
  45. Oct 4, 22:30  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Yifes
  46. Oct 4, 23:38   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Grokk
  48. Oct 5, 00:29   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview AnointedSword
  36. Oct 4, 19:35 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Dev
  38. Oct 4, 19:56  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Bhruic
  39. Oct 4, 20:11   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Cram
  43. Oct 4, 21:00    Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Sepharo
  44. Oct 4, 21:46     Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Slashman
  47. Oct 5, 00:27   Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Creston
>> 51. Oct 5, 01:02    Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Bhruic
  52. Oct 5, 01:38     Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Sepharo
  61. Oct 5, 12:46     Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Creston
  40. Oct 4, 20:33 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview jdreyer
  49. Oct 5, 00:31 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview AnointedSword
  53. Oct 5, 01:55  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Dev
  50. Oct 5, 00:37 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Acleacius
  57. Oct 5, 07:50 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Dapperdanman
  58. Oct 5, 10:37  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview El Pit
  59. Oct 5, 10:40 Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview Optional nickname
  60. Oct 5, 12:20  Re: Blue's Diablo III Beta Preview PHJF


footer

Blue's News logo