Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Greenbelt, MD 08/22

Regularly scheduled events

Op Ed

truepcgaming - Visual Noise: A Criticism of HUDs.
Having a playerís health, ammunition, inventory, and abilities always visible is a staple of the gaming medium, but one that we may be better off learning to deal without. I make this claim based solely on the experiences of noticing that virtually all games get better without an always-on interface. Iíve managed to nix 90% of the unnecessary HUD materials off New Vegas through two mods, and the result is a game that is unquestionably more immersive, balanced, difficult, and above all, beautiful.

View
15. Re: Op Ed Sep 17, 2011, 18:54 Ray Marden
 
In a general sense, I agree with the author. I am not looking at the HUD to experience the story, to challenge myself, out of some sense of fun, to notice some character moment, or to explore the world - it is just there to show me basic game mechanics.

When you take out the intrusive elements, I have frequently thought that games, even ones with "bad" graphics, look quite good or, at the very least, look interesting.

I know I will go to hell for this example, but I think WoW is a good example. There are all these characters from different races, there might be a gigantic lava elemental, you could be in an ancient temple, there are fantastical spell effects going off...yet all I am really doing is starting at my cooldowns on a bar and making sure there is no fire at the center of my screen. Who cares what this game or other games have to offer visually when all my focus is spent on only 20% of the screen?

From a broad perspective, I have found that I received many, many inquiries from casual gamers or non-gamers when there is little/no UI present (either via options or during a cinematic.)
And yeah, does my gun have to talk up 1/3 of my screen?
Thinking more work could be put into streamlining them,
Ray
 
Avatar 2647
 
Everything is awesome!!!
http://shoutengine.com/GarnettonGames/
I love you, mom.
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Sep 17, 12:22 Re: Op Ed Cutter
  3. Sep 17, 12:37  Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  4. Sep 17, 14:01   Re: Op Ed xXBatmanXx
  5. Sep 17, 14:01   Re: Op Ed [VG]Reagle
  6. Sep 17, 14:06    Re: Op Ed xXBatmanXx
  28. Sep 18, 13:52     Re: Op Ed [VG]Reagle
  8. Sep 17, 15:11  Re: Op Ed Warskull
  2. Sep 17, 12:30 Re: Op Ed Creston
  7. Sep 17, 14:37 Re: Op Ed m0deth
  9. Sep 17, 16:14  Re: Op Ed nin
  10. Sep 17, 16:18   Re: Op Ed Beamer
  11. Sep 17, 17:07    Re: Op Ed PHJF
  14. Sep 17, 18:24     Re: Op Ed Beamer
  12. Sep 17, 17:49 Re: Op Ed Dev
  13. Sep 17, 17:57 Re: Op Ed Caladell
>> 15. Sep 17, 18:54 Re: Op Ed Ray Marden
  16. Sep 17, 20:13  Re: Op Ed J
  17. Sep 17, 20:48   Re: Op Ed Jerykk
  19. Sep 17, 22:37    Re: Op Ed Asmo
  20. Sep 18, 00:06     Re: Op Ed MisterBenn
  18. Sep 17, 22:35 Re: Op Ed Rockn-Roll
  21. Sep 18, 04:53 Re: Op Ed Crustacean Soup
  22. Sep 18, 07:47  Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  23. Sep 18, 09:16   Re: Op Ed eRe4s3r
  24. Sep 18, 10:01    Re: Op Ed Slashman
  25. Sep 18, 11:12    Re: Op Ed Kajetan
  26. Sep 18, 11:55     Re: Op Ed DaHauns
  27. Sep 18, 13:43    Re: Op Ed yuastnav
  30. Sep 19, 09:37     Re: Op Ed eRe4s3r
  29. Sep 18, 17:54   Re: Op Ed Crustacean Soup


footer

Blue's News logo