Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
Customize
User Settings
Styles:
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:
Redding, CA 06/22
Tampa, FL 06/26
Tampa, FL 10/04

Regularly scheduled events

MechWarrior Legal Conflict

IGN reports on potential legal hurdles the recently announced MechWarrior revival from Piranha Games may have to overcome before its release. They have received a cease and desist order from Harmony Gold, co-copyright owner of the television series Robotech, demanding they remove the related MechWarrior teaser movie. IGN contacted Smith and Tinker about this, but received a "no comment" for the moment, and here's their outline of the dispute:

The letter claims that the use of certain trademarked figures from the Robotech/Macross universe are prohibited as a result of a prior settlement that dates back to 1996. While MechWarrior isn't part of the Robotech/Macross universe, the similarities between vehicles has been enough to cause legal issues and raise questions. Apparently, some of those trademarked figures appear in the trailer used by Piranha Games in its announcement of the MechWarrior reboot earlier this year, and a request has been made for that trailer to be pulled from IGN.

This development could put the future of MechWarrior in jeopardy. A trademark dispute could derail the game's development. On the flip side, it could also simply result in specific characters, logos, or other trademarked material from being included in the final product.

View
23. Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Sep 4, 2009, 13:59 Hump
 
That's not quite how trademarks work. If you don't enforce them, you establish a precedent, and before you know it everyone uses your stuff.

and thats the crux of the problem with copyright law. Creativity doesn't look towards the courts for inspiration, the best art is made by taking inspiration from what others have done before.

Anyhow, the author of the IGN piece is being a bit over-dramatic when he said it could put the future of the series in "jeopardy". Like someone said, they'll simply omit these mechs like they've done before.

I do agree though that using these mechs was a pretty idiotic move. Weisman, more than anyone, knows how Harmony Gold is. When I saw the Warhammer in the vid I was psyched because i assumed they had gotten permission. Evidently I give folks too much credit.
 
Avatar 10137
 
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Both the “left” and the “right” pretend they have the answer, but they are mere flippers on the same thalidomide baby, and the truth is that neither side has a clue."

- Jim Goad
Previous Post Next Post Reply Quote Edit Delete Report
 
    Date Subject Author
  1. Sep 4, 09:34 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict loomy
  2. Sep 4, 09:35  Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict BubbleMage
  3. Sep 4, 09:39   Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict UttiniDaKilrJawa
  4. Sep 4, 09:41 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Kajetan
  10. Sep 4, 10:42  Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict eRe4s3r
  11. Sep 4, 10:53   Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Raurus
  12. Sep 4, 11:30    Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Wildone
  13. Sep 4, 11:36     Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict eRe4s3r
  18. Sep 4, 13:15      Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Wowbagger_TIP
  22. Sep 4, 13:40       Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Burrito of Peace
  25. Sep 4, 16:17        Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict nutshell42
  26. Sep 4, 16:47         Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Kajetan
  27. Sep 4, 17:04         Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Cutter
  28. Sep 4, 17:25          Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Prez
  29. Sep 4, 17:36           Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Wowbagger_TIP
  30. Sep 4, 17:51            Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Talisorn
  31. Sep 4, 17:58           Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict  Blue 
  5. Sep 4, 09:43 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict LightAssassin
  6. Sep 4, 09:48  Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict InBlack
  7. Sep 4, 09:57   Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict TangledThorns
  8. Sep 4, 10:08    Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict NKD
  9. Sep 4, 10:11 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict LightAssassin
  14. Sep 4, 11:48 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict dagger
  15. Sep 4, 12:02  Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict eRe4s3r
  16. Sep 4, 12:16 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict dagger
  17. Sep 4, 12:45  Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict AnarKane
  19. Sep 4, 13:23   Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Creston
  21. Sep 4, 13:40    Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Aero
  20. Sep 4, 13:25 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict dubfanatic
>> 23. Sep 4, 13:59 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Hump
  24. Sep 4, 14:48  Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict Wowbagger_TIP
  32. Sep 4, 19:18 Re: MechWarrior Legal Conflict .net_Drifter
  33. Sep 4, 21:46 Re: MechWarrior Legal Woes Hump
  34. Sep 4, 23:57  Re: MechWarrior Legal Woes Supermike
  35. Sep 5, 17:08   Re: MechWarrior Legal Woes Jerykk
  36. Sep 5, 19:55    Re: MechWarrior Legal Woes Supermike
  37. Sep 6, 04:34     Re: MechWarrior Legal Woes Prez


footer

.. ..

Blue's News logo