Send News. Want a reply? Read this. More in the FAQ.   News Forum - All Forums - Mobile - PDA - RSS Headlines  RSS Headlines   Twitter  Twitter
User Settings
LAN Parties
Upcoming one-time events:

Regularly scheduled events

Report this Comment
Use this form to report the selected comment to the moderators. Reporting should generally be used only if the comment breaks forum rules.

89. Re: John Carmack Leaves id Software Nov 25, 2013, 02:26 Beamer
Jensen wrote on Nov 24, 2013, 04:15:
The last 3 id tech engines seem more like tech demos than well-rounded general purpose engines.
id Tech 3 : curved surfaces
id Tech 4 : unified lighting
id Tech 5 : Virtual Texturing (MegaTexture)

Rage has virtually no physics in it. I punch a skull attached to a rope and it makes a "thwump" sound and produces a small cloud of dust, but stays stationary. Even traffic cones won't budge. There's no HDR, which can be quite important for games with mixed indoors and outdoors.

John definitely got interested in different challenges. And they never hired a proper tools guy to support him, so UE3 took over. UE3 is a much better general purpose engine, with much better tools. For id tech 4, they definitely prioritized lighting over anything else, and while the lighting was cool, it was too soon for PCs to really handle, and the game they decided to build around it was no fun at all.

But a proper game designer and producer would have worked with John to create the right engine for the right game. Instead they never had the right design teams.
Anyone blaming Carmack for that forgets how, when Carmack tried to involve himself in game design, Paul Steed got fired. Carmack was the tech brains behind id, but he wasn't the one in charge (again, as the Steed firing proves.)
Music for the discerning:
Login Email   Password Remember Me
If you don't already have a Blue's News user account, you can sign up here.
Forgotten your password? Click here.


Blue's News logo